Review Process Policy

EDITORIAL QUALITY ASSURANCE

Review Process Policy

Assyfa Journal of Multidisciplinary Education applies a double-blind peer review process to support independent, fair, constructive, and evidence-based evaluation of scholarly manuscripts. Review procedures are designed to uphold academic quality, publication ethics, and editorial accountability.

1. Initial Editorial Screening

Each submission is initially assessed by an editor for relevance to the journal's focus and scope, manuscript completeness, originality, scholarly contribution, ethical compliance, and adherence to author guidelines. Manuscripts that fail essential criteria may be returned for correction or declined without external review.

2. Double-Blind Review and Anonymity

The journal uses a double-blind review model, under which author and reviewer identities are withheld from one another during the review process. Authors must prepare anonymized review files, removing identifying information where practicable. Editors take reasonable measures to protect reviewer confidentiality and prevent improper disclosure of manuscript contents.

3. Reviewer Selection and Assignment

Reviewers are selected on the basis of subject expertise, research experience, independence, and ability to provide a substantive assessment. The journal ordinarily seeks evaluations from two qualified reviewers for manuscripts proceeding to external peer review.

Additional reviews may be requested when reports conflict, specialist expertise is required, or important methodological concerns arise. Reviewer assignment is subject to disclosure and management of potential conflicts of interest.

4. Review Evaluation Criteria

Reviewers evaluate manuscripts according to relevant criteria, including:

  • Alignment with journal scope and educational relevance.
  • Originality, novelty, and research significance.
  • Adequacy of literature review and theoretical framework.
  • Methodological rigor, transparency, and validity.
  • Research ethics and responsible data reporting.
  • Quality of results, analysis, and interpretation.
  • Contribution to contextualized pedagogical innovation.
  • Educational implications, limitations, and conclusions.
  • Academic writing, referencing, and presentation.

Reviewers are expected to substantiate their assessments through specific, constructive comments and recommendations.

5. Review Timelines

Reviewers are ordinarily requested to complete their assessments within four weeks of accepting an assignment. Review completion times may vary with manuscript complexity, reviewer availability, and the need for additional evaluation. The editorial office may send reminders or reassign reviews when necessary to maintain an effective editorial workflow.

6. Editorial Decisions and Revisions

Reviewers provide advisory recommendations, which may include acceptance, minor revision, major revision, or rejection.

Editors consider the review reports, manuscript quality, research ethics, journal scope, and author responses when determining the appropriate editorial decision.

Authors invited to revise their manuscripts should submit a revised version together with a reasoned point-by-point response addressing reviewer and editorial comments. Revised manuscripts may undergo further review.

7. Research Integrity and Conflicts of Interest

Editors and reviewers must disclose relevant competing interests, maintain confidentiality, and refrain from exploiting unpublished information. Suspected plagiarism, fabricated data, inappropriate authorship, manipulated peer review, or other misconduct must be reported through the editorial process. Substantive concerns may require clarification, additional assessment, or institutional involvement.

8. Editorial Independence and Final Authority

The final editorial decision is made by the authorized Editor-in-Chief or delegated editor. Reviewer recommendations do not automatically determine acceptance. Publication fees, sponsorship, commercial interests, or personal relationships must not improperly influence editorial judgments.

9. Documentation and Accountability

The journal maintains editorial records within its publishing workflow, including manuscript submissions, reviewer assignments, review reports, revision requests, and editorial decisions. Access to confidential records is restricted according to authorized editorial roles and applicable privacy policies.