Retraction and Correction Policy

Retraction and Correction Policy

Research Integrity and Scholarly Record Management

Assyfa Journal of Multidisciplinary Education, published by CV. Bimbingan Belajar Assyfa, is committed to maintaining the reliability, transparency, accountability, and integrity of the scholarly record.

This policy establishes procedures for addressing errors, research integrity concerns, authorship disputes, publication misconduct, and other circumstances requiring post-publication editorial action.

The journal's approach is informed by the recommendations and principles of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) , including applicable guidance on corrections, expressions of concern, and retractions.

1. Purpose and Scope

This policy applies to articles already published by the journal, including online publications that have received official bibliographic records, publication dates, or DOIs.

The policy addresses:

  • Corrections of published articles.
  • Expressions of concern.
  • Retractions of unreliable or unethical publications.
  • Authorship and affiliation corrections.
  • Research integrity investigations.
  • Public editorial notices and recordkeeping.
  • Updates to OJS and DOI metadata.
  • Requests for reconsideration or appeal.

2. Types of Post-Publication Editorial Action

Editorial Action Purpose
Correction Correct a significant error without invalidating the overall findings.
Expression of Concern Alert readers to serious, unresolved concerns about a published article.
Retraction Identify a published article as unreliable or affected by a serious publication integrity issue.
Editorial Notice Communicate relevant editorial information requiring public clarification.

3. Article Corrections

Corrections may be issued when errors are identified that require amendment but do not substantially invalidate the article's overall scientific conclusions.

Examples include:

  • Incorrect article metadata.
  • Errors in author names or affiliations.
  • Incorrect figures, tables, or numerical values.
  • Errors in references or acknowledgments.
  • Omitted declarations or disclosures.
  • Other material errors requiring public clarification.

Corrections must clearly identify the original article, describe the relevant changes, and explain their effect on the published work.

Substantive corrections should be documented through a publicly accessible correction notice linked to the original publication.

4. Expressions of Concern

An Expression of Concern may be considered when credible questions arise regarding the reliability or integrity of published research, but available evidence does not yet support a definitive conclusion.

Such concerns may include:

  • Unresolved questions about research data.
  • Potentially serious authorship irregularities.
  • Concerns about ethical approval or consent.
  • Possible manipulation of the editorial process.
  • Ongoing investigations affecting research reliability.

An Expression of Concern should describe the nature of the concern without presenting unproven allegations as established facts.

Its status should be reviewed when relevant new evidence becomes available.

5. Grounds for Article Retraction

Retraction may be considered when reliable evidence demonstrates that a published article contains serious problems affecting its trustworthiness or legitimacy.

Circumstances may include:

  • Fabrication or falsification of research data.
  • Serious plagiarism or unauthorized reproduction.
  • Substantial duplicate or redundant publication.
  • Manipulation of the peer review process.
  • Unauthorized or fraudulent authorship.
  • Serious ethical violations involving research participants.
  • Unreliable findings resulting from major errors.
  • Other serious publication integrity violations.

Retraction is intended to correct the scholarly record and protect readers. It must not be used merely as a punitive measure against authors.

6. Investigation and Evidence Assessment

Reports of suspected publication misconduct should be assessed through a documented and impartial editorial process.

Depending on the concern, the investigation may involve:

  1. Recording the allegation or reported error.
  2. Conducting an initial editorial assessment.
  3. Preserving relevant submission and publication records.
  4. Reviewing available manuscripts, metadata, and correspondence.
  5. Requesting clarification from relevant parties.
  6. Evaluating supporting evidence and possible conflicts of interest.
  7. Determining an appropriate editorial response.
  8. Documenting and communicating the final outcome.

The journal may seek clarification from authors, reviewers, institutions, or other relevant parties when necessary and appropriate.

Confidential information must be protected throughout the investigation, subject to legitimate disclosure requirements.

7. Responsibilities of Authors

Authors are expected to cooperate with legitimate requests for clarification concerning published work.

Authors should promptly notify the editorial office when they discover significant errors, ethical concerns, or authorship irregularities affecting their articles.

A retraction decision does not always require unanimous author agreement when the available evidence establishes sufficient grounds for corrective action.

The journal should nevertheless seek relevant author responses and accurately document disagreements where appropriate.

8. Responsibilities of Editors

Editors are responsible for assessing publication concerns fairly, preserving editorial independence, and selecting corrective measures proportionate to the evidence.

Editors must disclose conflicts of interest that could compromise the handling of a case.

Cases involving potential misconduct by an editor should be referred to an independent, authorized editorial or publisher representative.

9. Responsibilities of the Publisher

CV. Bimbingan Belajar Assyfa supports transparent publication correction procedures, appropriate record preservation, and independent editorial assessment.

Publisher involvement in publication integrity investigations should respect due process, confidentiality, proportionality, and the separation between financial interests and editorial decisions.

10. Requirements for Retraction Notices

An official Retraction Notice should provide sufficient information for readers to identify the affected publication and understand why the retraction was issued.

The notice should include, where applicable:

  • The title of the affected article.
  • Relevant authorship and bibliographic details.
  • Volume, issue, and publication information.
  • The original article DOI or permanent URL.
  • The reason for retraction.
  • The party responsible for issuing the notice.
  • The date of the retraction decision or notice.
  • Relevant clarification concerning the available evidence.

A Retraction Notice must distinguish confirmed findings from unresolved allegations. It should avoid unnecessary personal information, speculative accusations, or unsupported statements.

Retraction Notice Principle

A retraction notice must be clear, identifiable, publicly accessible, linked to the affected article, and sufficiently informative to support responsible interpretation of the publication record.

11. Treatment of Retracted Articles

Retracted articles should ordinarily remain accessible through the journal website, clearly identified as retracted and linked to the corresponding Retraction Notice.

The published record should not be silently deleted or replaced. Removal of article content may be considered only in exceptional circumstances, such as significant legal, privacy, or safety concerns, with an appropriate public explanation where feasible.

If the original PDF remains accessible, its retracted status should be clearly communicated to readers.

12. OJS and DOI Metadata Corrections

Post-publication corrective actions should be reflected consistently across the journal's relevant records, as applicable.

These may include:

  • Article landing pages and publication status.
  • Article PDF files or accompanying notices.
  • Author names and affiliations.
  • Article titles and bibliographic information.
  • DOI registration and Crossref metadata.
  • Links between original articles and corrective notices.
  • Relevant indexing and discovery records.

Metadata updates must accurately represent the editorial action. Historical records should be preserved where required to maintain transparency and publication accountability.

A change made within OJS does not automatically guarantee that all external databases or DOI metadata records have been updated.

13. Authorship and Affiliation Corrections

Requests to correct author names, author order, affiliations, or contributor information must be supported by appropriate documentation.

Changes affecting authorship may require confirmation from relevant authors and investigation of any dispute or claim of unauthorized attribution.

Significant authorship irregularities may require an editorial notice, correction, or retraction, depending on their nature and effect on the scholarly record.

14. Complaints, Appeals, and Reconsideration

Individuals affected by a correction, expression of concern, or retraction may submit a documented request for reconsideration through official journal channels.

Requests should identify the publication concerned, the specific decision being challenged, the grounds for appeal, and any relevant evidence.

Appeals should be reviewed by an appropriate authorized representative who is not affected by a significant conflict of interest.

Reconsideration does not automatically suspend or reverse an existing corrective notice.

15. Confidentiality and Documentation

The editorial office should maintain appropriate records of complaints, supporting evidence, correspondence, investigation findings, decisions, and corrective actions.

Confidential documents must be managed according to applicable privacy and data protection requirements.

Public notices should provide sufficient transparency while avoiding unnecessary disclosure of confidential information.

16. Policy Review and Implementation

The journal may review this policy periodically to reflect developments in publication ethics, digital scholarly communication, metadata management, and applicable COPE guidance.

Effective implementation requires appropriately authorized editorial decisions, documented procedures, and coordinated updates to relevant publication records.

Scholarly Record Integrity Statement

Assyfa Journal of Multidisciplinary Education considers correction, expression of concern, and retraction essential mechanisms for preserving the reliability, transparency, and accountability of published research. Corrective actions are intended to protect the integrity of scholarly communication and provide readers with accurate publication information.

Related policies: Publication Ethics | Manuscript Withdrawal Policy | Privacy Statement | COPE