Conflict of Interest Policy

Conflict of Interest Policy

Disclosure, Independence, and Editorial Integrity

Assyfa Journal of Multidisciplinary Education, published by CV. Bimbingan Belajar Assyfa, is committed to maintaining transparency, impartiality, independence, and accountability throughout the scholarly publishing process. The journal requires authors, editors, reviewers, and other relevant participants to disclose interests that could influence, or reasonably appear to influence, their professional judgment.

This policy is informed by the principles of responsible publication practices promoted by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) .

1. Definition of Conflict of Interest

A conflict of interest exists when financial, professional, institutional, personal, academic, or other interests could influence, or reasonably be perceived as influencing, the conduct, interpretation, evaluation, or publication of scholarly research.

A conflict of interest does not necessarily indicate misconduct. However, relevant interests must be disclosed and appropriately managed to protect the integrity of the publication process.

2. Categories of Conflicts of Interest

Category Examples
Financial Research funding, consultancy, employment, honoraria, intellectual property, or financial relationships.
Institutional Shared affiliations, institutional responsibilities, or organizational interests.
Personal Family relationships, close friendships, personal disputes, or other relationships affecting impartiality.
Academic or Professional Recent research collaboration, supervisory relationships, academic competition, or professional dependencies.
Editorial Editorial responsibility combined with authorship, personal involvement, or influence over a manuscript decision.

3. Responsibilities of Authors

All authors must disclose relevant financial and non-financial interests that could affect the research or its presentation.

The declaration must be included in the manuscript and updated when relevant circumstances change during the editorial process.

Authors must also disclose funding sources and the role of funders, where applicable, in research design, data collection, analysis, interpretation, manuscript preparation, or publication decisions.

4. Declaration by Authors

Authors must include a dedicated section entitled Conflict of Interest Statement before the reference list.

Sample Declaration: No Conflict

The authors declare that they have no financial or non-financial conflicts of interest that could have influenced the research, interpretation, or publication of this manuscript.

Sample Declaration: Conflict Disclosed

The authors disclose the following relevant relationship or interest: [describe the relationship, funding, or competing interest]. The authors confirm that this interest has been transparently reported to the journal.

5. Responsibilities of Peer Reviewers

Reviewers must disclose potential conflicts of interest before accepting a manuscript review assignment.

Reviewers should decline or request reassignment when relevant relationships may compromise the independence or fairness of their evaluation.

Examples include recent collaboration with an author, a close professional or personal relationship, financial involvement, or direct competition affecting impartial judgment.

Reviewers must not use confidential manuscript information for personal, professional, or financial advantage.

6. Responsibilities of Editors

Editors must identify and disclose conflicts of interest that could compromise editorial independence or create a reasonable perception of bias.

An editor with a significant conflict must not exercise sole editorial authority over the affected manuscript. Editorial responsibility should be reassigned to an appropriately independent and authorized editor.

Editors must not use unpublished research, privileged editorial information, or confidential manuscripts for personal benefit.

7. Submissions by Editorial Board Members

Manuscripts submitted by editors, editorial board members, or individuals affiliated with the publisher must be evaluated using the journal's standard scholarly and ethical criteria.

Authors holding editorial roles must not participate in reviewer selection, confidential evaluation, or editorial decisions concerning their own manuscripts.

Such submissions should be managed by an independent editor with appropriate decision-making authority.

8. Responsibilities of the Publisher

CV. Bimbingan Belajar Assyfa supports editorial independence and transparent management of interests that may affect scholarly publishing.

Financial relationships, publication fees, sponsorship arrangements, and institutional interests must not determine manuscript acceptance, rejection, reviewer selection, or scholarly conclusions.

The publisher should provide appropriate oversight when conflicts affect editorial leadership or publication integrity investigations.

9. Conflict of Interest Management

When a potential conflict is identified, the editorial office should assess its nature, relevance, and possible influence on editorial procedures.

Depending on the circumstances, appropriate measures may include:

  • Requesting additional disclosure or clarification.
  • Documenting the relevant interests.
  • Reassigning a handling editor.
  • Appointing an independent reviewer.
  • Excluding a conflicted individual from a decision.
  • Seeking independent editorial advice.
  • Publishing an appropriate disclosure statement.

10. Disclosure During Peer Review

Authors, reviewers, and editors are expected to update their declarations whenever relevant new circumstances arise during the editorial process.

Identified conflicts should be evaluated before the affected participant continues with responsibilities that may compromise impartial assessment.

11. Undisclosed Conflicts of Interest

Failure to disclose a material conflict may result in editorial clarification, reassignment, investigation, or other appropriate measures.

When a significant undisclosed conflict is discovered after publication, the journal may evaluate whether a correction, editorial notice, expression of concern, or other action is necessary.

The nature and seriousness of the non-disclosure should be assessed in context. An undisclosed interest does not automatically invalidate a published article.

12. Confidentiality and Documentation

Conflict of interest disclosures and related editorial assessments should be documented and handled appropriately by authorized personnel.

Confidential information must be protected according to the journal's Privacy Statement and publication ethics requirements.

13. Post-Publication Concerns

Concerns about conflicts identified after publication may be submitted through official journal communication channels.

Substantiated concerns will be assessed under the journal's publication ethics and corrective action procedures.

14. Policy Review

The journal may periodically review and update this policy to reflect developments in scholarly publishing, editorial independence, responsible disclosure, and publication ethics.

Editorial Independence Statement

Assyfa Journal of Multidisciplinary Education requires transparent disclosure and appropriate management of competing interests to maintain independent peer review, fair editorial decision-making, and public confidence in scholarly publication.

Related policies: Publication Ethics | Peer Review Process | Complaints and Appeals Policy | Retraction and Correction Policy