Complaints and Appeals Policy

Complaints and Appeals Policy

Fairness, Accountability, and Editorial Integrity

Assyfa Journal of Multidisciplinary Education, published by CV. Bimbingan Belajar Assyfa, recognizes the importance of transparent, fair, and accountable procedures for handling complaints and appeals related to scholarly publishing.

This policy provides a structured framework for reporting concerns, requesting reconsideration of editorial decisions, and addressing potential violations of publication ethics. Its principles are informed by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) .

1. Scope of Complaints and Appeals

Authors, reviewers, readers, editorial personnel, and other relevant stakeholders may submit complaints or appeals concerning:

  • Editorial decisions and manuscript rejection.
  • Peer review procedures and reviewer conduct.
  • Unreasonable or unexplained editorial delays.
  • Authorship disputes or unauthorized authorship.
  • Plagiarism or other research integrity concerns.
  • Conflicts of interest and editorial misconduct.
  • Corrections, expressions of concern, and retractions.
  • Publication fees, invoices, and payment verification.
  • Privacy and confidentiality concerns.
  • Other matters affecting fair scholarly publication.

2. Types of Submissions

Category Description
Editorial Appeal A formal request to reconsider an editorial decision based on substantive reasons or evidence.
Procedural Complaint A concern regarding the fairness, consistency, or administration of editorial processes.
Ethics Allegation A report of suspected research misconduct or publication ethics violations.
Administrative Complaint A concern involving invoices, publication documentation, metadata, or other administrative matters.

3. Submission of Complaints

Complaints and appeals should be submitted through the journal's official communication channels. Authors with an active submission should use the relevant OJS editorial discussion whenever appropriate.

A complaint should include:

  1. Name and contact information of the complainant.
  2. Manuscript title and OJS Submission ID, if applicable.
  3. A clear description of the concern.
  4. Relevant dates and correspondence.
  5. Supporting documents or verifiable evidence.
  6. The requested clarification or corrective action.

Complainants should provide accurate information and avoid unsupported allegations or unnecessary disclosure of personal information.

4. Initial Assessment

Upon receiving a complaint, the authorized editorial office should assess whether the matter falls within the journal's responsibilities and whether sufficient information is available for further examination.

The journal may request additional information, clarify the nature of the complaint, or refer the matter to the appropriate responsible party.

Complaints involving immediate publication integrity risks should receive appropriate priority according to the seriousness of the concern.

5. Appeals Against Editorial Decisions

Authors may request reconsideration of an editorial decision when they identify substantial factual errors, procedural irregularities, or relevant scholarly evidence that was not adequately considered.

A disagreement with reviewer opinions alone does not automatically justify an appeal. Appeals must explain the specific basis for reconsideration.

An appeal should be evaluated by an appropriately authorized editor who can assess the matter impartially. Additional expert advice may be obtained when necessary.

An appeal does not guarantee reversal of the original editorial decision.

6. Peer Review Complaints

Complaints involving peer review may concern reviewer conduct, potential conflicts of interest, inappropriate comments, compromised confidentiality, or procedural irregularities.

The editorial office should examine relevant evidence while protecting confidential reviewer information and maintaining the integrity of the review process.

Appropriate responses may include clarification, reassessment, replacement of a reviewer, or additional independent review.

7. Research Integrity Complaints

Reports of suspected plagiarism, fabricated or falsified data, unauthorized authorship, duplicate publication, manipulated peer review, or other serious publication misconduct are handled under the journal's publication ethics procedures.

The editorial investigation may involve preservation of relevant records, clarification from affected parties, examination of supporting evidence, and consultation with appropriate institutions when necessary.

Suspected misconduct must not be presented as proven solely on the basis of an allegation or an automated screening result.

8. Conflicts of Interest and Independent Review

Individuals responsible for investigating a complaint must disclose relevant conflicts of interest.

Complaints involving an editor should be referred to another appropriately authorized representative who can review the matter independently.

Where a complaint concerns the journal's editorial leadership, referral to an authorized publisher representative or other impartial mechanism may be appropriate.

9. Confidentiality and Protection

Complaints, appeals, supporting documents, and investigation records should be handled confidentially to the extent appropriate and consistent with applicable legal and ethical requirements.

The journal seeks to prevent retaliation against individuals who raise concerns in good faith. Complaints should be assessed based on relevant evidence rather than the identity or institutional standing of the complainant.

The confidentiality of peer review and unpublished manuscripts must be protected throughout the process.

10. Right to Respond

Individuals whose actions are questioned should be provided a reasonable opportunity to explain their position and provide relevant evidence before adverse conclusions are finalized, where appropriate.

The editorial office should assess the available information impartially and distinguish verified facts from disputed or incomplete claims.

11. Possible Outcomes

Depending on the evidence and the nature of the complaint, outcomes may include:

  • Written clarification or explanation.
  • Correction of administrative information.
  • Reassessment of an editorial decision.
  • Additional independent peer review.
  • Correction of published metadata.
  • Review of authorship documentation.
  • Referral for an ethics investigation.
  • Publication of a correction or expression of concern.
  • Retraction when justified by the evidence.
  • Closure of the complaint when unsupported.

Decisions should be proportional to the evidence and should respect the applicable editorial policies.

12. Communication of Decisions

The journal should communicate the outcome of a complaint or appeal to the relevant parties through an appropriate official channel.

Responses should explain the principal basis of the decision while respecting confidentiality and legitimate restrictions on sensitive information.

Complex investigations may require additional time, particularly when external evidence or institutional clarification is necessary.

13. Recordkeeping and Accountability

The editorial office should maintain appropriate records of complaints, correspondence, supporting evidence, investigation steps, decisions, and corrective actions.

Such records should be accessible only to authorized personnel according to their responsibilities and applicable privacy requirements.

14. Administrative and Financial Complaints

Complaints concerning Article Processing Charges, payment verification, invoices, publication documentation, or administrative errors should be submitted through official journal channels with relevant supporting records.

Publication fee disputes must be handled separately from independent editorial assessment. Payment status must not determine scholarly acceptance or rejection.

Authors should consult the official Author(s) Fee policy for applicable charges and payment procedures.

15. Policy Review

The journal may periodically review this policy to strengthen fairness, accountability, transparency, and compliance with evolving publication ethics standards.

Editorial Fairness Commitment

Assyfa Journal of Multidisciplinary Education is committed to evaluating complaints and appeals impartially, protecting editorial independence, respecting the rights of relevant parties, and maintaining accountability throughout the scholarly publishing process.

Related policies: Publication Ethics | Retraction and Correction Policy | Peer Review Process | Privacy Statement