Preprint and Prior Publication Policy

Preprint and Prior Publication Policy

Originality, Research Transparency, and Responsible Scholarly Dissemination

Assyfa Journal of Multidisciplinary Education, published by CV. Bimbingan Belajar Assyfa, recognizes the importance of early scholarly communication and responsible dissemination of research findings. The journal establishes this policy to distinguish legitimate preprints, academic repository deposits, conference presentations, and thesis-based manuscripts from unacceptable duplicate or redundant publication.

The journal's assessment of prior dissemination is informed by recognized publication ethics principles, including guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

1. Purpose and Scope

This policy applies to manuscripts submitted to the journal that have previously been shared, presented, deposited, or disseminated in another form.

Authors must disclose relevant prior dissemination and ensure that the submitted manuscript meets the journal's originality and publication ethics requirements.

2. Preprint Definition

A preprint is a scholarly manuscript made publicly available before formal journal publication, typically without completing the journal's peer review and editorial production process.

A preprint may be deposited in an institutional repository, disciplinary repository, or recognized preprint server.

Preprint dissemination does not automatically constitute prior journal publication. Its acceptability depends on the manuscript's publication history, applicable rights, and the journal's editorial assessment.

3. Preprints and Manuscript Submission

The journal permits consideration of manuscripts previously deposited as preprints, provided that the authors transparently disclose the preprint and comply with relevant copyright and publication ethics requirements.

Authors must provide:

  • The preprint title.
  • The name of the preprint server or repository.
  • The preprint DOI or permanent URL, where available.
  • The date of public dissemination.
  • Relevant differences between the preprint and submitted manuscript.

The editorial office may assess whether previous dissemination presents concerns regarding originality, authorship, copyright, or research integrity.

4. Thesis and Dissertation-Based Articles

Manuscripts developed from undergraduate theses, master's theses, doctoral dissertations, or other academic degree research may be considered for publication.

Authors must disclose the academic source when relevant and ensure that the journal manuscript presents an appropriately developed scholarly contribution.

The manuscript should not merely reproduce an entire thesis or dissertation without appropriate adaptation, clear academic focus, and compliance with copyright requirements.

The existence of a thesis in an institutional repository does not automatically disqualify a related journal manuscript.

5. Conference Presentations and Proceedings

Research previously presented at conferences, seminars, symposiums, or academic meetings may be considered for journal publication.

Authors must disclose whether the work appeared only as an abstract, presentation, poster, unpublished conference paper, or full proceedings article.

Manuscripts previously published as full proceedings articles require particular editorial assessment. Authors must demonstrate a substantial and identifiable scholarly contribution beyond the previous publication.

Substantial overlap, copyright restrictions, and publication history must be disclosed. Citation of the earlier proceedings publication is required when relevant.

6. Duplicate and Redundant Publication

The journal does not accept duplicate or redundant publication presented as original scholarly work.

Duplicate publication may involve publishing substantially the same research findings, data, analyses, or conclusions in multiple scholarly venues without appropriate disclosure or justification.

Authors must not submit manuscripts that have already been published in substantially the same form as peer-reviewed journal articles.

7. Salami Publication

Salami publication refers to the inappropriate fragmentation of a research study or dataset into multiple publications with insufficient independent scholarly contributions.

Multiple articles derived from the same project or dataset may be acceptable when each addresses a genuinely distinct research question and provides a substantive contribution.

Authors must disclose related publications and explain the distinct contribution of the submitted work.

8. Simultaneous Submission

Authors must not submit substantially the same manuscript simultaneously to multiple journals.

Manuscripts under active consideration elsewhere must not be submitted to this journal until the previous editorial process has formally ended.

9. Required Prior Publication Declaration

Authors must provide a Prior Publication and Preprint Declaration when their manuscript has been previously disseminated in a relevant form.

Example A: Preprint Disclosure

An earlier version of this manuscript was deposited as a preprint in [repository or server name] on [date], available at [DOI or permanent URL]. The authors have disclosed the prior dissemination to the journal.

Example B: Thesis-Based Manuscript

This manuscript was developed from the thesis or dissertation entitled [title], completed at [institution] in [year]. The submitted article presents [describe the scholarly contribution or adaptation].

Example C: Conference Disclosure

A preliminary version of this research was presented at [conference] on [date]. Details of any previous proceedings publication and relevant differences have been disclosed to the journal.

Example D: No Prior Dissemination

The authors declare that this manuscript has not been previously published and is not under consideration for publication elsewhere.

10. Copyright and Licensing

Authors are responsible for ensuring that earlier dissemination does not conflict with applicable copyright agreements, repository conditions, or third-party intellectual property rights.

The journal's current open-access licensing policy uses the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0) for newly published articles, subject to the applicable article-level license.

11. Updating Preprints After Publication

After formal journal publication, authors are encouraged to update the relevant preprint or repository record with a citation and DOI link to the published version.

Authors must respect the repository's versioning procedures and avoid presenting an earlier preprint as the final peer-reviewed version without clarification.

12. Editorial Assessment

Editors may request copies of related publications, links to preprints, similarity reports, or explanations of overlapping materials.

The editorial decision will consider originality, scholarly contribution, disclosure, copyright, and the journal's publication ethics requirements.

A similarity percentage alone does not determine whether prior publication is acceptable. Contextual editorial evaluation is required.

13. Non-Disclosure and Misconduct

Failure to disclose relevant prior dissemination may result in requests for clarification, manuscript rejection, or investigation under the journal's publication ethics procedures.

If serious duplicate publication concerns are identified after publication, the journal may consider correction, expression of concern, or retraction based on the evidence.

14. Policy Review

This policy may be reviewed periodically to reflect developments in preprint practices, scholarly publishing, copyright, and publication ethics.

Prior Publication Transparency Statement

Assyfa Journal of Multidisciplinary Education supports responsible early dissemination of research while requiring accurate disclosure, original scholarly contributions, compliance with copyright, and prevention of duplicate or misleading publication.

Related policies: Publication Ethics | Screening Plagiarism Policy | Author Guidelines | Copyright Notice