This is an Creative Commons License This work is licensed under a Creative Commons

Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License

Jurnal Inovasi dan Pengembangan Hasil Pengabdian Masyarakat

e-ISSN 3025-2334

Vol 2(1), June 2024, 1-12

DOI: https://doi.org/10.61650/jip-dimas.v2i1 .307

Implementing Blended Learning in

Vocational High Schools: A

Comprehensive Workshop

Rusjdy Sjakyakirti Arifin

, Dina Febriani Darmansyah

, Rikaro Ramadi

, Muhammad Dandi Alfariji

, Ahmad

Maulana Dhaifullah

, and Muhammad Fa’iq Wijaya

2, 3, 4, 5, 6

Universitas Muhammadiyah Jakarta, Indonesia

Corresponding author:

rusjdy.arifin@umj.ac.id

KEYWORDS

Blended Learning, Distance

learning, E-learning,

Instructional Technology

SUBMITTED:

09/09/2023

REVISED:

10/12/2023

ACCEPTED:

10/2/2024

ABSTRACT:

The COVID-19 pandemic underscored the importance of integrating technology into education,

revealing the potential of e-learning to enhance instructional efficacy and efficiency. To retain these benefits

post-pandemic, this study focuses on implementing Blended Learning—a pedagogical approach combining

traditional face-to-face instruction with online learning—specifically in vocational senior high schools.

Despite its advantages, many schools have yet to incorporate Blended Learning due to various challenges.

This community service initiative aims to equip vocational school instructors and educational personnel with

the necessary skills to proficiently integrate Blended Learning into their teaching practices. The program

encompasses workshops and technical training sessions, meticulously structured into three phases:

assessment, implementation, and evaluation. The workshop is scheduled for August 2023 and targets

educators and other educational professionals, providing them with hands-on experience and practical

knowledge. Preliminary outcomes indicate that participants comprehensively understood Blended Learning's

advantages and demonstrated a robust readiness to implement this hybrid instructional strategy, evidenced

by pre- and post-workshop assessments and feedback surveys.

INTRODUCTION

The COVID-19 pandemic has forced educational institutions worldwide to adapt to digital learning

environments rapidly (Gómez et al., 2023; Wahjono & Wiyono, 2021), highlighting the critical need for

integrating technology into traditional teaching methods (Fatchurahman, 2021; Johler, 2022). Despite the

evident necessity and potential benefits (Behnke, 2023; Yulianeta et al., 2024), the shift to Blended Learning

has encountered numerous challenges (Kumar et al., 2021), particularly in vocational senior high schools

(Ali et al., 2023a, 2023b). Previous research has identified several barriers to implementing Blended

Learning in these settings, including technological infrastructure limitations, lack of digital literacy among

educators, and resistance to change from traditional teaching methodologies.

Empirical evidence from studies conducted during the pandemic reveals that many schools struggled

with inadequate internet access and digital devices (R. S. Arifin et al., 2024; Wang et al., 2020), hindering

the smooth transition to online learning. For instance, a study by Johnson et al. (2021) found that

approximately 40% of vocational schools lacked the necessary technological infrastructure to support

Blended Learning effectively (Z. Arifin et al., 2024). Furthermore, educators often lacked the training and

skills required to design and deliver online components of their courses. According to a survey by Smith

and Brown (2020), nearly 60% of vocational school teachers reported feeling unprepared to integrate

digital tools into their instruction.

Arifin, R . et al., ││ Implementation of Blended...

JIPDIMAS: Journal of Innovation and Development of Community Service Results | 1-12

The rapid transition to online learning during the COVID-19 pandemic has fundamentally transformed

the educational landscape, particularly accentuating the pivotal role of technology in modern pedagogy

(Nursaid et al., 2023). One significant approach that has gained traction is Blended Learning (Suharsiwi et

al., 2023), which synergizes traditional face-to-face classroom methods with innovative online instructional

techniques. This hybrid model not only enhances the flexibility and accessibility of education but also

fosters a more engaging and personalized learning experience for students. Implementing Blended

Learning in vocational senior high schools holds promise for significantly improving instructional outcomes

by leveraging the strengths of both in-person and digital learning environments.

Empirical evidence underscores the efficacy of Blended Learning in various educational settings

(Schabas, 2023). Studies by Bernard et al. (2014) and Means et al. (2013) have demonstrated that students

in Blended Learning environments tend to outperform their peers in traditional settings. These findings are

particularly relevant for vocational education, where hands-on skills and theoretical knowledge must be

seamlessly integrated. For instance, a study by López-Pérez et al. (2011) found that using Blended Learning

in vocational training programs led to higher student engagement (Bieri et al., 2023; Grønlien et al., 2021;

Nong et al., 2023), and improved practical skill acquisition (Haningsih et al., 2022; Mohammed et al., 2021),

and better academic performance.

The COVID-19 pandemic drastically altered the education landscape worldwide, pushing institutions

to adopt e-learning solutions rapidly (Kalyniuk et al., 2024; Pradana & Uthman, 2023; Zhi & Thoe, 2024).

This sudden shift highlighted the significant role that technology can play in enhancing instructional

methods and making education more accessible and flexible (Karim & Zoker, 2023; Sungkawati & Uthman,

2024). There is a compelling need to sustain these advancements post-pandemic to ensure continued

educational improvement and resilience (Alkhatib & Jaradat, 2021; Zairul et al., 2023). Blended Learning,

which merges traditional classroom activities with online learning, emerges as a promising approach to

achieve this goal (Wijaya & Darmayanti, 2023; Winson et al., 2024). This pedagogical method leverages the

strengths of both face-to-face and digital instruction, offering a more personalized and engaging learning

experience. However, despite its potential benefits, the adoption of Blended Learning in vocational senior

high schools remains limited.

Several barriers impede the widespread implementation of Blended Learning in these institutions

(Nursaid et al., 2024; Utomo, 2024). Many vocational schools lack the technical infrastructure (Lubis, 2024)

and resources to support this hybrid model (Zahroh et al., et al., 2023). Additionally, there is a pervasive

deficiency in teacher training (Liani et al., 2024), leaving educators ill-prepared to effectively integrate

digital tools into their teaching practices (Zamzam et al., 2024). Moreover, resistance to change poses a

significant challenge (Zahroh et al., 2023); educators accustomed to traditional instructional methods often

express concerns about the increased workload and the complexity of managing both online and offline

components (Arma, 2024; Mas’odi & Arma, 2024). This reluctance is further compounded by doubts

regarding the efficacy of digital pedagogy—a sentiment echoed in the research by Lee and Kim (2019),

which emphasizes the need for targeted support to facilitate this transition.

This research initiative proposes a comprehensive workshop tailored for vocational senior high school

educators and educational personnel to address these challenges. The workshop aims to provide

participants with the skills and knowledge necessary to implement Blended Learning proficiently. The

program is structured into three phases—assessment, implementation, and evaluation—offering hands-on

training and practical insights into effectively integrating blended learning strategies. Scheduled for August

2023, the initiative is designed to foster a robust understanding ofBlended Learning's advantages and

prepare educators to overcome the associated challenges. By equipping educators with the requisite

competencies, this initiative aspires to bridge the gap between current educational practices and the

transformative potential of Blended Learning, ultimately enhancing the instructional landscape and better

preparing students for the modern workforce.

Arifin, R . et al., ││ Implementation of Blended...

JIPDIMAS: Journal of Innovation and Development of Community Service Results | 1-12

METHOD

This study employs a mixed-methods approach, combining both qualitative and quantitative research

methodologies to thoroughly explore the implementation of Blended Learning in vocational senior high

schools. The research process is divided into several systematic and sequential steps to ensure

comprehensive data collection and analysis. The reviews and mixed-method technique can be seen in

Figure 1.

Figure 1: steps for implementing this research method

Figure 1 Analysis of mixed method technique, where this rigorous approach ensures a comprehensive

and unbiased synthesis of existing research. The are follows:

1. Needs Assessment

This initial phase involves conducting surveys and interviews with vocational school instructors and

educational personnel to identify their current technological competencies and the specific challenges they

face in integrating Blended Learning. The data collected will help tailor the workshop content to address

the participants' needs effectively. Empirical evidence from previous studies, such as those by Means et al.

(2013) and Graham (2012), will be referenced to support the assessment's findings.

2. Workshop Design and Development

Based on the needs assessment, a detailed workshop curriculum is developed. This curriculum includes

modules on the fundamentals of Blended Learning, effective online instructional strategies, and hands-on

sessions for using various e-learning platforms and tools. The design phase also incorporates the creation

of instructional materials and assessment instruments, ensuring they align with the learning outcomes.

3. Implementation Phase

The workshop is conducted over a series of sessions in August 2023. Each session includes lectures,

practical exercises, and group discussions to facilitate active learning. Participants engage in simulated

teaching scenarios to practice the integration of Blended Learning into their instructional practices.

Empirical studies, such as those by Horn and Staker (2015), are used to demonstrate the effectiveness of

Blended Learning in enhancing student engagement and learning outcomes.

4. Evaluation and Feedback

Arifin, R . et al., ││ Implementation of Blended...

JIPDIMAS: Journal of Innovation and Development of Community Service Results | 1-12

The workshop's effectiveness is assessed through pre- and post-workshop evaluations, including

surveys, focus group discussions, and observational studies. These assessments measure participants'

knowledge gain, confidence levels, and readiness to implement Blended Learning. Feedback from

participants is also collected to refine future workshops and address any gaps in the training.

Table 1. The following table summarizes the methodological steps:

Step

Description

Empirical Evidence

Needs

Assessment

Surveys and interviews to identify technological

competencies and challenges

Means et al. (2013),

Graham (2012)

Workshop

Design and

Development

Creation of workshop curriculum and

instructional materials

Implementation

Phase

Conducting workshop sessions with practical

exercises

Horn and Staker (2015)

Evaluation and

Feedback

Pre- and post-workshop evaluations, focus group

discussions

By systematically following these steps, this study aims to provide vocational school instructors with the

necessary skills and knowledge to implement Blended Learning effectively, ultimately enhancing the

quality of education in vocational senior high schools.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Implementing Blended Learning in vocational senior high schools presents a multifaceted challenge

that requires a thorough exploration of various dimensions. This section is structured to elucidate the

findings from the workshop and provide a detailed discussion on the following subtopics:

A. Understanding of Blended Learning Concepts

The workshop began with assessing participants' baseline understanding of Blended Learning

concepts. Initial surveys revealed that while most educators were familiar with e-learning, there was

limited knowledge about blending it with traditional teaching methods. Post-workshop assessments

showed a significant improvement in comprehension, with 95% of participants demonstrating a clear

understanding of how to integrate online and face-to-face instruction effectively. This finding aligns with

prior research by Graham et al. (2013), which emphasizes the necessity of professional development in

enhancing educators' proficiency in Blended Learning.

To understand Blended Learning concepts better, it is essential to consider the perspectives of various

experts and the empirical evidence supporting these findings. According to Garrison and Vaughan (2008),

Blended Learning offers a middle ground that leverages the strengths of face-to-face and online learning

environments, creating a more engaging and flexible learning experience. This hybrid approach can address

diverse learning needs and improve student outcomes by providing multiple avenues for interaction and

feedback.

In a comparative study by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD,

2015), countries like Finland and Singapore have successfully adopted Blended Learning in their

educational frameworks. These countries reported enhanced student engagement and academic

performance, attributing their success to comprehensive training programs for educators. For instance,

Finnish educators undergo rigorous professional development that includes workshops and continuous

support, similar to the structure implemented in our study.

Empirical evidence from a study by Means et al. (2010) further supports these findings. Their meta-

analysis of Blended Learning implementations across various educational settings revealed that students

in Blended Learning environments performed better, on average than those in traditional face-to-face or

fully online courses. This performance boost is often linked to the flexibility and personalized learning

opportunities that Blended Learning provides.

The data collected from our workshop participants mirror these global trends. Pre-workshop surveys

Arifin, R . et al., ││ Implementation of Blended...

JIPDIMAS: Journal of Innovation and Development of Community Service Results | 1-12

indicated that 60% of participants had a rudimentary understanding of Blended Learning, primarily

focused on e-learning components. Post-workshop surveys, however, demonstrated a marked increase in

knowledge, with 95% exhibiting a solid grasp of blending both instructional methods effectively. This

significant improvement underscores the efficacy of hands-on training and professional development in

elevating educators' capabilities in implementing Blended Learning.

Overall, the results from our workshop are consistent with global research and practices, highlighting

the critical role of professional development in enhancing the understanding and application of Blended

Learning concepts. These findings suggest that with adequate training and resources, vocational senior high

schools can effectively integrate Blended Learning, thereby enriching the educational experiences of both

teachers and students.

Table 2: Pre- and Post-Workshop Assessment Results

Assessment Criteria

Pre-Workshop (%)

Post-Workshop (%)

Basic Understanding of E-

Learning

100

Knowledge of Blended Learning

Concepts

Confidence in Implementing

Blended Learning

Perceived Advantages of

Blended Learning

This table summarizes the pre- and post-workshop assessment results, illustrating the marked

improvement in participants' understanding and confidence in Blended Learning concepts. These empirical

results, supported by previous studies, affirm the positive impact of structured professional development

programs on educators' proficiency in integrating Blended Learning into their teaching practices.

B. Technical Skills and Digital Literacy

A critical component of the workshop was enhancing the educators' technical skills and digital

literacy—hands-on training sessions equipped participants with the tools and techniques to create and

manage online content. Empirical evidence from the workshop indicated that participants' confidence in

using educational technology increased by 80%, as measured by pre- and post-training surveys. This boost

in digital literacy is consistent with the findings of Means et al. (2014), who highlighted the importance of

technical training in the successful implementation of Blended Learning.

1. Further Exploration: Technical Skills and Digital Literacy

To delve deeper into the topic, it is essential to consider various perspectives from different experts

and countries. For instance, a study by Drijvers et al. (2016) in the Netherlands found that professional

development programs focusing on digital competence significantly enhanced teachers' abilities to

effectively integrate technology into their teaching practices. Similarly, a European Commission (2013)

report on "Opening Up Education" emphasizes that developing digital literacy is crucial for modern

educators and can lead to improved student outcomes.

In the United States, the Department of Education (2017) research highlighted that teachers who

underwent digital literacy training were more adept at utilizing educational technology and demonstrated

higher levels of instructional innovation. This was supported by the findings of Heggart & Yoo (2018), who

showed that teachers with robust technical skills were better prepared to implement Blended Learning,

leading to more engaging and interactive classroom environments.

The empirical evidence supporting these findings is substantial. For example, Table 3 below compares

the pre- and post-training survey results from our workshop participants, showcasing significant

improvements in their technical skills and digital literacy:

Table 3. Technical Skill and Digital literasi

Arifin, R . et al., ││ Implementation of Blended...

JIPDIMAS: Journal of Innovation and Development of Community Service Results | 1-12

Metric

Pre-Training

Score (%)

Post-Training

Score (%)

Improvement

(%)

Confidence in using learning

management systems (LMS)

Ability to design online instructional

content

Proficiency in using digital

collaboration tools

These results align with previous studies and underscore the necessity of comprehensive technical

training programs. The enhanced digital literacy among educators prepares them for the immediate

implementation of Blended Learning and also positions them to continuously adapt to future technological

advancements in education.

In conclusion, our workshop participants' improved technical skills and digital literacy confirm that

targeted training programs are essential to successfully adopting Blended Learning. By drawing on the

experiences and findings from various countries and experts, we can better understand the critical role of

digital literacy in modern education and work towards more effective and inclusive learning environments.

C. Curriculum Design and Pedagogical Strategies

Effective Blended-Learning necessitates thoroughly redesigning curriculum and pedagogical

strategies to integrate online and offline instructional elements seamlessly. The workshop highlighted the

importance of aligning learning objectives with blended instructional methods, emphasizing the need for a

balanced approach that leverages the strengths of both traditional and digital learning environments.

Participants were actively involved in collaborative activities to develop lesson plans that effectively

combined face-to-face and online components. The feedback collected indicated a high level of satisfaction

among the participants regarding the practical applicability of the strategies discussed.

Table 4: Comparative Analysis of Blended Learning Curriculum Design Across Different Countries

Country

Curriculum Design

Approach

Key Pedagogical

Strategies

Empirical Evidence

United

States

Modular curriculum

with flexible

pathways

Flipped Classroom,

Project-Based

Learning

Horn and Staker (2015)

demonstrated improved student

engagement and performance.

Finland

Integrated

curriculum with

cross-disciplinary

projects

Collaborative

Learning, Inquiry-

Based Learning

Research by Kumpulainen and

Mikkola (2014) showed

enhanced critical thinking and

problem-solving skills.

Singapore

Curriculum

emphasizing ICT

integration

Blended

Synchronous

Learning, Peer

Tutoring

Studies by Tan and Choo (2016)

revealed higher student

motivation and learning

outcomes.

Research by Horn and Staker (2015) underscores the significance of curriculum redesign in achieving

desired educational outcomes. Their work illustrates that when learning objectives are aligned with

blended instructional methods, students experience enhanced engagement and academic performance.

Similarly, a study by Kumpulainen and Mikkola (2014) in Finland found that integrating collaborative and

inquiry-based learning strategies within a blended learning framework significantly improved students'

critical thinking and problem-solving abilities.

In Singapore, Tan and Choo (2016) explored the impact of ICT-integrated curriculum on student

learning. Their findings suggest that blended synchronous learning and peer tutoring increased student

motivation and led to better learning outcomes. These empirical studies support the notion that a well-

designed blended learning curriculum that thoughtfully incorporates online and offline pedagogical

strategies can substantially enhance the educational experience.

The workshop's approach to curriculum design and pedagogical strategies mirrors these successful

Arifin, R . et al., ││ Implementation of Blended...

JIPDIMAS: Journal of Innovation and Development of Community Service Results | 1-12

models, equipping vocational school educators with the tools and knowledge necessary to implement

effective blended learning environments. By engaging in hands-on activities and collaborative planning,

participants could contextualize theoretical insights into practical applications, thereby fostering a more

dynamic and interactive learning atmosphere in their respective institutions.

D. Challenges in Implementation

Despite the positive reception of Blended Learning among vocational senior high school instructors

and educational personnel, several challenges were identified that could hinder its full implementation.

Among the most notable challenges are resistance to change, limited technological access, and insufficient

infrastructure. These obstacles are not unique to this study but are widely recognized in the academic

community, as highlighted by research from various experts and countries.

1. Resistance to Change

Resistance to change is a significant barrier in adopting Blended Learning. Many educators are

accustomed to traditional teaching methods and may feel uncomfortable or unprepared to integrate digital

tools into their instruction. A study by Ertmer and Ottenbreit-Leftwich (2010) underscores that teachers'

beliefs about technology and their self-efficacy significantly influence their willingness to adopt new

teaching practices. Training programs must, therefore, not only focus on technical skills but also address

these psychological barriers to foster a more receptive attitude toward Blended Learning.

2. Limited Access to Technology

Limited access to technology is another critical challenge. In many vocational senior high schools,

particularly those in rural or underfunded areas, there is a stark disparity in the availability of necessary

technological resources. According to a report by the World Bank (2020), schools in low and middle-income

countries face significant gaps in access to computers, reliable internet, and other digital tools essential for

Blended Learning. Consequently, educational institutions must prioritize investments in technological

infrastructure to bridge this gap and provide equitable learning opportunities.

Table 5. Limited Access to technology

Challenge

Description

Supporting Studies

Resistance to Change

Educators' reluctance to adopt new methods due

to comfort with traditional practices.

Ertmer & Ottenbreit-

Leftwich (2010)

Limited Access to

Technology

There are disparities in the availability of digital

tools, especially in rural or underfunded schools.

World Bank (2020)

Insufficient

Infrastructure

Lack of necessary facilities to support Blended

Learning, including reliable internet and

hardware.

Picciano et al. (2013)

3. Insufficient Infrastructure

Insufficient infrastructure further complicates the implementation of Blended Learning. This includes

not only the physical hardware and internet connectivity but also technical support and maintenance

availability. Picciano et al. (2013) argue that without robust infrastructure, the potential benefits of Blended

Learning cannot be fully realized. Empirical evidence from their study indicates that schools with better

infrastructural support show higher rates of successful Blended Learning adoption.

In conclusion, while implementing Blended Learning is promising to enhance educational outcomes in

vocational senior high schools, addressing these challenges is crucial. Ongoing support and investment from

educational institutions, along with targeted training programs that consider both technical and

psychological aspects, are essential for overcoming these barriers and ensuring the successful integration

of Blended Learning into the educational landscape.

E. Impact on Student Engagement and Learning Outcomes

Arifin, R . et al., ││ Implementation of Blended...

JIPDIMAS: Journal of Innovation and Development of Community Service Results | 1-12

Preliminary observations from participants indicated that Blended Learning has the potential to

enhance student engagement and learning outcomes. Educators reported that integrating online resources

and interactive activities increased student participation and motivation. This observation is corroborated

by empirical studies, such as those by Dziuban et al. (2018), which found that Blended Learning

environments can improve academic performance and student satisfaction.

To delve deeper into blended learning's impact on student engagement and learning outcomes,

examining findings from various studies and contexts is essential. For example, a study conducted in the

United States by Means et al. (2013) revealed that students in Blended Learning environments performed

better than their counterparts in traditional settings. This study highlighted the importance of well-

designed and interactive online content, facilitating higher student engagement and understanding levels.

A study from Australia by Ginns and Ellis (2007) also supports these findings. Their research showed

that students in Blended Learning courses exhibited higher satisfaction levels and better learning outcomes

than traditional face-to-face courses. Using multimedia resources and online discussion forums was

particularly effective in keeping students engaged and motivated.

Additionally, research from Malaysia by Norazah Nordin et al. (2016) found that Blended Learning

positively impacted students' critical thinking skills and overall academic performance. The flexibility of

accessing learning materials online allowed students to learn at their own pace, leading to a deeper

understanding of the subject matter. To provide a comprehensive overview, Table 6 summarizes the key

findings from these studies:

Table 6. Findings underscore

Study

Country

Key Findings

Means et al. (2013).

USA

Students in Blended Learning environments performed

better academically.

Ginns and Ellis (2007)

Australia

Higher student satisfaction and learning outcomes in

Blended Learning courses.

Norazah Nordin et al.

(2016)

Malaysia

Improved critical thinking skills and overall academic

performance.

These empirical findings underscore the potential of Blended Learning to enhance student engagement

and learning outcomes across different educational contexts. The integration of technology in education not

only makes learning more interactive and engaging and provides students with the flexibility to tailor their

learning experiences to their individual needs. As vocational senior high schools continue to adopt Blended

Learning, designing and implementing these programs thoughtfully is crucial to maximize their educational

benefits.

CONCLUSION

The workshop on implementing Blended Learning in vocational senior high schools represents a

pivotal step toward modernizing educational practices and enhancing instructional efficacy. The initiative

has successfully equipped educators and educational personnel with the necessary skills to integrate

Blended Learning into their teaching methodologies through a meticulously structured program

encompassing assessment, implementation, and evaluation phases. The hands-on experience during the

workshops allowed participants to gain practical knowledge and a comprehensive understanding of

Blended Learning's advantages.

As evidenced by pre- and post-workshop assessments and participant feedback, preliminary

outcomes indicate a significant improvement in educators' readiness to adopt this hybrid instructional

strategy. Participants reported increased confidence and competence in utilizing technology to enhance

their teaching practices, which is essential for meeting the evolving educational needs of students in a post-

pandemic world. The workshop addressed the immediate need for technological integration and laid the

foundation for sustainable instructional improvements in vocational education.

Arifin, R . et al., ││ Implementation of Blended...

JIPDIMAS: Journal of Innovation and Development of Community Service Results | 1-12

In conclusion, the successful implementation of Blended Learning in vocational senior high schools

through targeted workshops demonstrates the potential for this pedagogical approach to revolutionize

education. By combining traditional face-to-face instruction with online learning, Blended Learning offers

a flexible, efficient, and practical education delivery. The positive outcomes from this initiative underscore

the importance of continued support and development in this area, ensuring that educators are well-

prepared to navigate the future of education with confidence and innovation.

REFERENCES

Ali, K., Alhaija, E. S. A., Raja, M., Zahra, D., Brookes, Z. L., McColl, E., Zafar, S., Kirnbauer, B., Al Wahadni, A. M.,

Al-Fodeh, R. S., Bani-Hani, T. G., Daher, S. O., & Daher, H. O. (2023a). Blended learning in undergraduate

dental education: a global pilot study. Medical Education Online, 28(1).

https://doi.org/10.1080/10872981.2023.2171700

Ali, K., Alhaija, E. S. A., Raja, M., Zahra, D., Brookes, Z. L., McColl, E., Zafar, S., Kirnbauer, B., Al Wahadni, A. M.,

Al-Fodeh, R. S., Bani-Hani, T. G., Daher, S. O., & Daher, H. O. (2023b). Blended learning in undergraduate

dental education: a global pilot study. Medical Education Online, 28(1).

https://doi.org/10.1080/10872981.2023.2171700

Alkhatib, A. S., & Jaradat, S. A. (2021). The Impact of Blended Learning using the Ideas Box on the Motivation

for Learning Among Non-formal Syrian Female Refugee Students in Jordan. International Journal of

Interactive Mobile Technologies, 15(11), 81 – 95. https://doi.org/10.3991/ijim.v15i11.21961

Arifin, R. S., Darmansyah, D. F., Ramadi, R., Alfariji, M. D., Dhaifullah, A. M., & Wijaya, M. F. (2024).

Implementing Blended Learning in Vocational High Schools: A Comprehensive Workshop. Jurnal

Inovasi Dan Pengembangan Hasil Pengabdian Masyarakat, 1, 1–12.

Arifin, Z., Saputra, A. B., & Jaenullah, J. (2024). Model Pembelajaran Berbasis Web (E Learning) Pada

Pembelajaran PAI. Assyfa Journal of Multidisciplinary Education, 2.

Arma, I. P. (2024). Characters and Non-Digital Media: Case Study Trends in English Language Learning in

Secondary Schools. Assyfa Journal of Multidisciplinary Education, 2, 95–103.

Behnke, C. (2023). Blended Learning in the Culinary Arts: Tradition Meets Technology. In Blended Learning:

Across the Disciplines, Across the Academy. Taylor and Francis.

https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003443285-2

Bieri, J., Tuor, C., Nendaz, M., Savoldelli, G. L., Blondon, K., Schiffer, E., & Zamberg, I. (2023). Implementation

of a Student-Teacher–Based Blended Curriculum for the Training of Medical Students for

Nasopharyngeal Swab and Intramuscular Injection: Mixed Methods Pre-Post and Satisfaction Surveys.

JMIR Medical Education, 9. https://doi.org/10.2196/38870

Fatchurahman, M. (2021). Blended Learning Problems in Terms Of Psychology. CV.

Gómez, C. J., Hinojo-Lucena, F. J., Moreno-Vera, J. R., & Alonso-Garcia, S. (2023). Analysis of a forced blended-

learning program in social sciences higher education during the COVID-19 post-pandemic. Education

and Training, 65(2), 298 – 311. https://doi.org/10.1108/ET-06-2022-0246

Grønlien, H. K., Christoffersen, T. E., Ringstad, Ø., Andreassen, M., & Lugo, R. G. (2021). A blended learning

teaching strategy strengthens the nursing students’ performance and self-reported learning outcome

achievement in an anatomy, physiology and biochemistry course – A quasi-experimental study. Nurse

Education in Practice, 52. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nepr.2021.103046

Haningsih, S., Harimurti, S. M., & Budiwati, A. (2022). Blended Learning in Islam Ulil Albab Course and Its

Contribution To Enhance Students’ Piety; [Blended Learning dalam Mata Kuliah Islam Ulil Albab dan

Kontribusinya Untuk Meningkatkan Ketakwaan Mahasiswa]. Millah: Journal of Religious Studies, 21(2),

491 – 522. https://doi.org/10.20885/millah.vol21.iss2.art7

Johler, M. (2022). Collaboration and communication in blended learning environments. Frontiers in

Education, 7. https://doi.org/10.3389/feduc.2022.980445

Kalyniuk, N. M., Franchuk, V. V, Selskyy, P. R., Humenna, N. V, & Hladii, O. I. (2024). Blended form of

education as an innovative approach in the training of medical students: The experience of Ukraine;

[La educación semipresencial Como enfoque innovador en la formación de estudiantes de medicina:

Arifin, R . et al., ││ Implementation of Blended...

JIPDIMAS: Journal of Innovation and Development of Community Service Results | 1-12

la experiencia de Ucrania]. Educacion Medica, 25(6). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.edumed.2024.100965

Karim, S., & Zoker, E. M. (2023). Technology in Mathematics Teaching and Learning: An Impact Evaluation

in Selected Senior Schools in Masingbi Town. Assyfa Learning Journal, 2, 60–72.

Kumar, A., Krishnamurthi, R., Bhatia, S., Kaushik, K., Ahuja, N. J., Nayyar, A., & Masud, M. (2021). Blended

Learning Tools and Practices: A Comprehensive Analysis. IEEE Access, 9, 85151–85197.

https://doi.org/10.1109/ACCESS.2021.3085844

Liani, H., Mardiana, J., Hermaliza, S., Ananda, S. D. F., & Andriani, O. (2024). Teacher Problems on Children

with Special Needs, Special Intelligence/Special Talents in Learning Process. Assyfa Journal of

Multidisciplinary Education, 1, 1–4.

Lubis, M. (2024). Digital learning media in elementary science: stimulating or demotivating? Assyfa Journal

of Multidisciplinary Education, 1, 18–26.

Mas’odi, M., & Arma, I. P. (2024). Characters and Non-Digital Media: Case Study Trends in English Language

Learning in Secondary Schools. Assyfa Journal of Multidisciplinary Education, 2.

Mohammed, T. A. S., Al-Sowaidi, B., & Banda, F. (2021). Towards a technology-enhanced blended approach

for teaching arabic for s ri’ purposes (Asp) in the light of the south african national qualifications

framework. International Journal of Information and Education Technology, 11(1), 1 – 9.

https://doi.org/10.18178/ijiet.2021.11.1.1481

Nong, W., Ye, J.-H., Chen, P., & Lee, Y.-S. (2023). A study on the blended learning effects on students majoring

in preschool education in the post-pandemic era: An example of a research-method course in a Chinese

university. Frontiers in Psychology, 13. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2022.962707

Nursaid, N., Haanurat, A. I., & Rahman, A. (2023). Exploring the Shari’ah economic learning model through

virtual learning: Initiatives and challenges. Assyfa Journal of Islamic Studies, 2.

Nursaid, N., Nuraini, S., & Novitasari, D. R. (2024). How" influence" do media, facilities, and learning interests

influence students’ economic learning outcomes? Assyfa Journal of Multidisciplinary Education, 1.

Pradana, M. D., & Uthman, Y. O. O.-O. (2023). Development of Aqidah Akhlak Learning Media" Board Game

Based on Education Fun on the Theme of Commendable Morals (E-Fun A2M)" for High School

Students. Assyfa Learning Journal, 1, 25–36.

Schabas, A. (2023). Game-based science learning: what are the problems with teachers practicing it in class?

Assyfa Learning Journal, 2, 89–103.

Suharsiwi, S., Lestari, J. T., & Karim, S. (2023). Islamic content-based learning: Kindergarten illustrated

narrative song" Lulu and Tom". Assyfa Journal of Islamic Studies, 1.

Sungkawati, E., & Uthman, Y. O. O.-O. (2024). Adopting the Blue Green Economy Term to Achieve SDGs in

Digital Learning: Opportunities and Challenges for Indonesia. Assyfa Learning Journal, 2, 84–98.

Utomo, D. P. (2024). Machine Learning Analysis of Junior High Students’ Math Representation in HOTS

Problems. Assyfa Learning Journal, 2, 133–147.

Wahjono, H., & Wiyono, B. B. (2021). Development of Blended-Learning-Based Semester Credit System

Implementation Model to Improve Learning Service. Information (Switzerland), 12(12).

https://doi.org/10.3390/info12120511

Wang, L., Huang, Y., & Omar, M. K. (2020). Analysis of Blended Learning Model Application Using Text

Mining Method. International Journal of Emerging Technologies in Learning, 16(1), 172–187.

https://doi.org/10.3991/IJET.V16I01.19823

Wijaya, W. A., & Darmayanti, R. (2023). Independent Learning Curriculum: What is the teacherâ€

s role in

facilitating effective learning. Assyfa International Scientific Journal, 1.

Winson, V. R. V, Narayana, S. T. V, Sailaja, S. V, & Kashyap, A. M. N. (2024). Augmentation of Collaborative

Learning for Design (Engineering) Subjects in Remote Learning. Assyfa Learning Journal, 1, 1–9.

Yulianeta, Y., Hardini, T. I., Wirza, Y., Haerudin, D., & Amandangi, D. P. (2024). Bridging Cultures:

Empowering BIPA Educators in Australia through Local Indonesian Wisdom Training. Jurnal Inovasi

Dan Pengembangan Hasil Pengabdian Masyarakat, 1.

Zahroh, U., Rachmawati, N. I., & Darmayanti, R. (2023). Significance of Collaborative Learning Guidelines in

21st Century Education on Functional Limits Material in Madrasah Tsanawiyah. Assyfa Journal of

Arifin, R . et al., ││ Implementation of Blended...

JIPDIMAS: Journal of Innovation and Development of Community Service Results | 1-12

Islamic Studies, 2, 155–161.

Zahroh, U., Rachmawati, N. I., Darmayanti, R., & Tantrianingrum, T. (2023). “ Guidelines” for collaborative

learning in 21st century education at Madrasah Tsanawiyah. Assyfa Journal of Islamic Studies, 2.

Zairul, M., Azli, M., & Azlan, A. (2023). Defying tradition or maintaining the status quo? Moving towards

a new hybrid architecture studio education to support blended learning post-COVID-19. Archnet-IJAR:

International Journal of Architectural Research, 17(3), 554 – 573. https://doi.org/10.1108/ARCH-11-

2022-0251

Zamzam, R., Novitasari, D. R., & Suharsiwi, S. (2024). The" E-RAISE Model" exploration of science challenges

and cultural values improves learning outcomes. Assyfa Journal of Multidisciplinary Education, 1, 27–

32.

Zhi, G. X., & Thoe, N. K. (2024). HARMONIZING TECHNOLOGY AND TRADITION: THE IMPACT OF BLENDED

TEACHING IN CHINESE PRIMARY AND SECONDARY MUSIC EDUCATION; [HARMONIZANDO

TECNOLOGIA E TRADIÇÃO: O IMPACTO DO ENSINO COMBINADO NA EDUCAÇÃO MUSICAL PRIMÁRIA

E SECUNDÁRIA EM CHINÊS]. Revista de Gestao Social e Ambiental, 18(4).

https://doi.org/10.24857/rgsa.v18n4-098