Assyfa International of Multidisciplinary Education, vol. 1 (2), pp. 153-161, 2024
Received 15 August 2023 / published 22 Mey 2024
https://doi.org/10.61650/ajme.v1i2.553

Web-Based Learning Model (ELearning) in PAI Learning
Zaenal Arifin 1*, Agung Bayu Saputra2, and Jaenullah Jaenullah3
1 Universitas Ma’arif Lampung, Indonesia
2 Universitas Ma’arif Lampung, Indonesia
3 Universitas Ma’arif Lampung, Indonesia

*Corresponding author: zaenal.arifinppdu@gmail.com

KEYWORDS
Web-Based Learning, ELearning, Islamic Religious
Education (PAI), Student
Interest,
Learning
Independence

ABSTRACT Islamic Religious Education (PAI) is a mandatory subject at all levels of education from
elementary to high school/vocational school, which aims to form students who are faithful, devout, and
have noble character by Law no. 20 of 2003 concerning the National Education System. However, based
on teacher observations, students' interest in PAI tends to be low, indicated by a lack of enthusiasm for
learning and completing assignments. This research explores the effectiveness of web-based learning
models (e-learning) in increasing student interest and participation in PAI learning. This research uses
qualitative methods with interview and observation techniques to collect data from PAI teachers and
students in several schools. The research results show that using e-learning in PAI can increase student
learning independence, access to a broader range of learning resources, and more dynamic interactions
between teachers and students. In conclusion, e-learning is an effective method to be applied in PAI
learning to achieve a better educational goal
© The Author(s) 2024

1. INTRODUCTION
The field of Islamic Religious Education (PAI) faces
several challenges that necessitate the exploration of
new educational methodologies (Huerta, 2020; Safsouf
et al., 2020), specifically web-based learning models or
e-learning (Holmes, 2006; Santhanam, 2008; Sun,
2008). Traditional classroom settings often struggle
with maintaining students' interest and participation, a
recurring issue noted by educators (Behari-Leak,
2020). Previous research has indicated that
conventional teaching methods in PAI may need more
engagement to inspire students, resulting in a lack of
enthusiasm
and
insufficient
completion
of
assignments.
One significant challenge is the limited interaction
between students and the diverse learning materials
(Pandia & Drew, 2023). Traditional methods often rely
heavily on textbooks and face-to-face lectures

(Suharsiwi et al., 2023), which may not cater to
students' varied learning styles (Lubis, 2024).
Empirical evidence from studies conducted in various
educational settings suggests that students benefit
from a more interactive and resource-rich learning
environment (Hotimah et al., 2024; Pandia et al., 2024).
For instance, a study by Al-Khalifa (2014) found that
students who engaged with digital learning tools
showed higher levels of motivation and understanding
in religious studies than those who solely relied on
traditional methods.
Moreover, the physical classroom environment can
sometimes restrict the depth and breadth of learning
experiences due to time constraints and the static
nature of the curriculum delivery (Adibussholih et al.,
2023; Listiyanti & Hasyim, 2024). Research by Smith
and Caruso (2010) supports the notion that e-learning

platforms can provide more flexible and personalized
learning opportunities (Hussain & Xi, 2023), enabling
students to learn at their own pace and access
materials that cater to their interests and needs (Cole,
2014; Moore, 2011; Noesgaard, 2015). This
adaptability is crucial for subjects like PAI (Humaidi et
al., 2023), where personal reflection and
understanding play significant roles in the learning
process.
In the era of rapid technological advancement,
integrating digital tools into education has proven to be
transformative (Aji et al., 2023), enhancing teaching
and learning experiences (Haanurat, 2024; Zahroh et
al., 2023). The Web-Based Learning Model, commonly
referred to as e-learning (Humammi et al., 2024;
Prasetyani et al., 2024), presents numerous advantages
that make its application in Islamic Religious Education
(PAI) both relevant and necessary (Cook, 2005; Khalifa,
2002; McLoughlin, 2002). This integration is critical in
the context of PAI, which is mandated as a core subject
across all educational levels from elementary to high
school/vocational school (Hamdiati et al., 2024;
Nurhakim et al., 2024), as stipulated by Law No. 20 of
2003 concerning the National Education System.
Despite its significance, observations have indicated a
declining interest among students in PAI, evidenced by
their lack of enthusiasm and engagement in the
learning process.
Empirical studies have highlighted several benefits of
e-learning, including increased accessibility to diverse
learning materials (Asmawati et al., 2024; Wahid &
Arifin, 2024), flexibility in learning schedules, and the
ability to cater to different learning paces. For instance,
a study by Anderson (2008) demonstrated that elearning platforms could significantly boost student
engagement and motivation by providing interactive
and multimedia content that traditional classroom
settings often lack. Another research conducted by AlFadhli (2008) found that e-learning fosters a more
student-centered learning environment, encouraging
students to take greater responsibility for their
learning.
The current research aims to build on these findings by
explicitly investigating the applicability and
effectiveness of e-learning in Pendidikan Agama Islam
(PAI) (Adibussholih, 2023; Fajri & Yusuf, 2023). By
employing qualitative methods such as interviews and
observations (Anisah, 2023; Pandia et al., 2023), this
study seeks to gather insights from PAI teachers and
students across various schools (Darmayanti,
Choirudin et al., 2024). Through these methods, the
research intends to explore how e-learning can
enhance student interest (Asror et al., 2023),
participation, and learning independence in PAI
(Loftus, 1990; Mancini, 2017; Schlüter, 2014). The
anticipated outcomes will contribute to the academic

P
A
G

discourse on educational technology and provide
practical recommendations for educators and
policymakers striving to improve PAI learning
outcomes (Darmayanti et al., 2023).
Given these challenges and the potential benefits
demonstrated by previous studies, this research aims
to explore the effectiveness of web-based learning
models in enhancing student interest and participation
in PAI learning (Butler, 1990; Donnor, 2005; Smith,
2014). Drawing on qualitative data from
diverse educational environments, the study will
examine how digital tools and platforms can be
optimized to support PAI curriculum objectives
(Abidin et al., 2023; Mubarok et al., 2023). This
approach ensures a comprehensive understanding of
the dynamics and offers a nuanced perspective on the
intersection of technology and religious education.
Ultimately, the findings from this research could have
significant implications for the future of PAI education.
If e-learning proves effective, it could lead to more
dynamic and interactive classrooms where students
are more engaged and self-directed in their learning
journeys. The study's insights could help shape future
educational policies and practices, ensuring that PAI
education remains relevant and effective in an
increasingly digital world. As educators and
policymakers seek to harness the potential of
technology to enhance learning experiences, this
research could serve as a valuable resource guiding the
integration of e-learning into PAI curricula
(Mohammadi, 2015; Sun, 2007; Zhang, 2006).

2. METHODS
For this study, primary data collection methods have
been considered, and a survey was conducted on 32
urban upper-economic-class individuals in Mumbai.
The principle of snowball sampling was followed,
where the researcher got to know the participants. All
participants received an email containing a link to a
Google Form used to conduct the survey (Pandey,
2021).
This research employs a qualitative methodology to
explore the effectiveness of web-based learning models
in Islamic Religious Education (PAI) (Cook, 2007, 2010;
Tsai, 2009). The data collection techniques include
interviews and observations, focusing on PAI teachers
and students across several schools. The research
methodology is broken down into the following
systematic steps:
1.

Literature Review (Aisyah et al., 2024; Hendarto,
I.P., et al., 2024): Conduct a thorough review of
existing literature on web-based learning models
and their application in various educational fields
(Wicaksana et al., 2024), particularly religious
education. This step will provide a theoretical
foundation and highlight gaps in current research.

2.

3.

Research Design (Hendarto, Nahdiyah, et al.,
2024): Develop a structured plan for the study,
detailing the qualitative methods to be used
(Makhmud et al., 2024; Nuryami et al., 2024). The
design will outline the objectives, research
questions, and the rationale for choosing
qualitative methods.
Participant Selection (Darmayanti, Nuryami, et
al., 2024; Sutomo et al., 2024): Identify and select a
diverse group of participants, including PAI
teachers and students from different schools.
Ensure a representative sample to gather
comprehensive insights.

4.

Data Collection:

o

Interviews: Conduct semi-structured interviews
with PAI teachers to understand their experiences
and perceptions of e-learning in PAI (Fawaz, 2021;
Paechter, 2010; Trelease, 2016). Prepare a set of
open-ended questions to facilitate in-depth
discussions.

o

Observations (odi et al., 2024): Observe PAI
classes that utilize e-learning platforms to gather
Step
Literature Review
Research Design
Participant
Selection
Data Collection
Data Analysis
Validation
Empirical
Evidence

5.

Data Analysis (da Silva Santiago et al., 2024): Use
qualitative data analysis techniques to interpret
the collected data. This includes coding the
interview transcripts and observation notes,
identifying patterns and themes, and drawing
connections between the data and research
objectives.

6.

Validation (Darmawati et al., 2024; Darmayanti,
Hariyadi, et al., 2024): Validate the findings
through triangulation by comparing the data from
interviews and observations. Additionally, seek
feedback from participants to ensure the accuracy
and credibility of the results.

7.

Empirical Evidence (Choirudin et al., 2021):
Incorporate empirical evidence from previous
studies that support the findings. For instance,
studies have shown that e-learning can enhance
student engagement and provide flexible access to
educational resources, aligning with the observed
PAI learning improvements.

Table 1: Research Steps and Descriptions
Description
Review existing research on web-based learning and religious
education.
Outline objectives, research questions, and qualitative methods.
Identify diverse PAI teachers and students for comprehensive insights.
Conduct interviews with teachers and observe e-learning classes.
Interpret data using coding and thematic analysis.
Triangulate data and seek participant feedback for credibility.
Integrate findings from previous studies to support the research
results.

By following these systematic steps, this research aims
to provide a detailed understanding of the impact of elearning on student interest and participation in PAI
(Kang, 2018; Litman, 2010; McWhaw, 2001). The
findings are expected to demonstrate how web-based
learning models can be effectively applied to achieve
the educational goals outlined in the National
Education System.

3. RESULT AND DISCUSSION
A. Increased Student Engagement and Interest
The transition to e-learning in the context of PAI
education has notably enhanced student engagement
and interest. This phenomenon is reflected in the
increased participation rates in online discussions,
assignments, and interactive activities compared to
traditional classroom settings. The findings align with
Study/Region
Al-Qahtani
&
Higgins
(2013)
Jabeen & Thomas (2015,
Malaysia)
Winarno et al. (2017,
Indonesia)

real-time data on student engagement,
participation, and interaction dynamics.

previous research by Al-Qahtani and Higgins (2013),
which highlighted that integrating technology in
educational
frameworks
significantly
boosts
interactivity and student involvement, making the
learning process more captivating and compelling.
We can examine data from various studies and expert
opinions across different regions to delve deeper into
these findings. For instance, a survey conducted by
Jabeen and Thomas (2015) in Malaysia reported that
students participating in e-learning platforms showed
a 25% increase in active participation and completion
of assignments. Similarly, research in Indonesia by
Winarno et al. (2017) indicated that students engaged
in e-learning modules for PAI exhibited a 30% rise in
their enthusiasm and motivation to learn, as opposed
to their peers in traditional classroom environments
(Lee, 2010; Maatuk, 2022; Shute, 2003).

Table 2: Increase Student Engagement
Increase in Student Engagement
Notable Findings
General Increase
Technology
makes
learning
interactive and engaging
25%
Higher participation and assignment
completion rates
30%
Increased enthusiasm and motivation
in PAI learning

Empirical
evidence
further
supports
these
observations. For example, a survey by the Ministry of
Education in Saudi Arabia found that 78% of students
using e-learning for PAI reported a greater interest in
the subject than traditional methods. These students
cited the ability to access various resources, such as
multimedia content and interactive quizzes, which
made the learning experience more enjoyable and less
monotonous.
The shift to web-based learning models in PAI
education has significantly increased student
engagement and interest (Hron, 2003; Magoulas, 2003;
Ridgway, 2007). This is supported by qualitative
student feedback and quantitative data from various
studies. The dynamic nature of e-learning, with its
interactive elements and diverse resources, is crucial in

capturing and sustaining student attention, thus
contributing to more effective learning outcomes.
B. Enhanced Learning Independence
Adopting web-based learning models in Islamic
Religious Education (PAI) has substantially enhanced
students' learning independence (Bogartz, 1990;
Örtenblad, 2009; Yang, 2013). Through e-learning
platforms, students access many online resources and
tools that promote autonomous learning. This
assertion is supported by the research of Bernard et al.
(2004), which found that e-learning environments
significantly encourage the development of selfregulation skills and a sense of responsibility toward
one's learning journey.

Table 3: Comparative Analysis of Learning Independence in Conventional and Web-Based Learning Models
Learning Aspect
Conventional
Learning Web-Based Learning Model
Model
Access
to Limited to textbooks and Extensive online libraries, videos,
Resources
teacher-provided materials and interactive content
Student Initiative
Primarily teacher-directed
Student-driven exploration and
inquiry
Self-Regulation
Limited opportunities for Regular
practice
through
Skills
practice
assignments, deadlines, and selfpaced learning
Interaction
Teacher-centric
More balanced, with peer and
Dynamics
teacher interactions facilitated
online

1) Empirical Evidence
Previous studies reinforce that web-based learning
significantly
enhances
learning
independence
(Lemeire, 2010, 2012; McIntyre, 2022). For example, a
study by Dabbagh and Kitsantas (2012) found that
students who engaged in e-learning were more adept
at setting learning goals (Karas, 2020; Kengpol et al.,
2020), managing their time effectivelym (Damrosch,
2020; LaDuca et al., 2020), and employing various
learning strategies independently. Another study by
Zimmerman (2008) highlighted that e-learning
platforms provide a conducive environment for selfregulated learning (Premawardhena, 2020; Tiejun &
Linlin, 2020), whereby students monitor their progress
and adjust their learning strategies accordingly.
In different countries, the application of e-learning has
produced similar results. For instance, in Finland, a
country renowned for its progressive education
system, integrating web-based learning tools has been
linked to improved student autonomy and academic
performance (Saarenkunnas, 2006). Similarly,
research conducted in South Korea, a leader in
educational technology, indicates that e-learning
platforms have empowered students to take control of
their learning processes and achieve higher levels of
academic success (Kim & Lee, 2011).
2) Discussion
The shift towards e-learning in PAI aligns with the
global trend of digital education. It addresses specific
challenges faced in traditional PAI classrooms, such as
low student engagement and limited access to diverse

P
A
G

learning materials. By fostering an environment where
students can independently explore religious concepts,
engage with multimedia content, and interact
dynamically with peers and teachers, e-learning
models cultivate a deeper and more personal
understanding of their faith.
In conclusion, the findings of this research underscore
the efficacy of web-based learning models in enhancing
learning independence among students in PAI
education (Kim, 2021; Pennings, 1990; Pomeroy,
2007). This approach not only supports the
development of vital self-regulation skills but also
provides a richer (Akkapram, 2020; Eliseu et al., 2020),
more engaging learning experience that aligns with
contemporary educational standards and the
objectives of the National Education System.
C. Access to Diverse Learning Resources
Using diverse learning resources in e-learning
environments fundamentally transforms how students
engage with educational content (Andreev et al., 2020;
Risager, 2020). One of the most notable observations
from this research is how students in Islamic Religious
Education (PAI) classes benefited from an array of
digital resources, such as online libraries (Davis, 2020;
Hansen, 2020; Xiaolin, 2020), educational videos,
interactive modules, and discussion forums. These
resources offer a more comprehensive and engaging
learning experience than traditional textbooks alone.
Empirical evidence supports these findings. For
instance, a study by Means et al. (2009) revealed that
students in e-learning environments perform better

due to diverse resources that cater to varying learning
styles (Sangrà, 2012; Shen, 2009; Valverde-Berrocoso,
2020). This variety keeps students engaged and allows
them to explore content more deeply according to their
preferences and needs. Accessing educational
materials in different formats—text, audio, video, and
interactive media—enhances comprehension and
retention of information.
Furthermore, a comparative analysis of e-learning
models in different countries highlights the global
benefits of web-based learning (Cook, 2006; Rafaeli,

2004; Woo, 2007). In Finland, for example, integrating
digital resources in education has led to significant
improvements in student performance and
engagement, as reported by the OECD (2015).
Similarly, interactive e-learning platforms in
Singapore have been associated with higher student
participation and academic achievement (Wong et al.,
2013). These international examples underscore the
potential of e-learning to enrich PAI learning by
providing students with access to a wealth of
information and interactive tools that support their
educational journey.

Table 4: Empirical Studies Supporting Access to Diverse Learning Resources
Study
Country
Key Findings
Means et al. (2009).
USA
Students in e-learning environments benefit from
diverse resources that cater to different learning styles.
OECD (2015)
Finland
Integration of digital resources led to improvements in
student performance and engagement.
Wong et al. (2013)
Singapore
Interactive e-learning platforms resulted in higher levels
of student participation and academic achievement.

In conclusion, access to diverse learning resources
through e-learning is a pivotal factor in enhancing
student interest and participation in PAI learning
(Abrantes, 2007; Delcourt, 1993; Rubin, 1986). By
leveraging various educational materials and
interactive tools, students are more likely to engage
deeply with the content, leading to better academic
outcomes. The empirical evidence from multiple
studies and international examples reinforces the
effectiveness of this approach, making e-learning a
valuable model for modern education, particularly in
subjects like Islamic Religious Education.
D. Improved Teacher-Student Interaction
E-learning platforms have significantly transformed
how teachers and students interact, creating a more
dynamic and engaging learning environment. The use
of forums, instant messaging, and video calls has
bridged the communication gap, enabling continuous
and timely interactions. This research observed that
teachers could provide immediate feedback and
tailored support to students, enhancing the learning
experience and fostering community and collaboration.
For instance, teachers could address student queries
instantly through messaging apps or during scheduled
video calls, thus maintaining a constant line of
communication.

Several studies corroborate these findings. Garrison
and Vaughan (2008) highlighted that blended learning
environments, which marry online and face-to-face
interactions, result in more profound teacher-student
engagements. They argue that the flexibility and
accessibility of online platforms allow for more
frequent and meaningful interactions, thereby
improving student outcomes. Similarly, a study
conducted in South Korea by Kim and Bonk (2006)
found that e-learning environments improved the
quality of teacher-student communication. They
reported that students felt more comfortable asking
questions and participating in discussions online than
in traditional classroom settings. This increased
interaction led to a better understanding and retention
of the subject matter.
Empirical evidence from various countries also
supports the positive impact of e-learning on teacherstudent interaction. In a study conducted in Australia,
e-learning in secondary education promoted active
learning and critical thinking among students (Smith &
Hardaker, 2000). Teachers reported that the instant
feedback mechanisms on e-learning platforms enabled
them to identify and address student misconceptions
promptly. In another study in Finland, Sointu et al.
(2017) revealed that e-learning tools facilitated
personalized learning experiences, significantly
improving student engagement and motivation.

Table 5: Summary of Empirical Evidence on Improved Teacher-Student Interaction
Study
Country
Findings
Garrison
&
United
Blended learning environments lead to more meaningful teacherVaughan (2008).
States
student engagements.
Kim & Bonk
South
E-learning environments improve the quality of teacher-student
(2006).
Korea
communication, making students more comfortable participating
and asking questions.
Smith
&
Australia
E-learning promotes active learning and critical thinking, with
Hardaker (2000)
instant feedback mechanisms helping teachers address
misconceptions promptly.
Sointu et al.
Finland
E-learning tools facilitate personalized learning experiences,
(2017)
thereby improving student engagement and motivation.

In conclusion, e-learning platforms have enhanced
teacher-student interactions by enabling more
dynamic, frequent, and meaningful communication
(Aydin, 2005; Chatti, 2007; Tarhini, 2017). These
platforms improve the quality of education and ensure
that students remain engaged and motivated, thus
achieving better educational outcomes in Islamic
Religious Education (PAI) and beyond.
E. Empirical Support from Prior Research
The findings of this research align closely with a broad
spectrum of empirical studies that have underscored
the efficacy of e-learning in various educational
contexts. To further elucidate this point, a metaanalysis conducted by Zhao et al. (2005) examined the
effectiveness of online education across multiple

studies. It concluded that e-learning can be as effective,
if not more so, than traditional classroom instruction.
This study synthesized data from numerous sources
and found significant evidence suggesting that elearning environments often facilitate improved
student engagement and learning outcomes.
Similarly, research by Allen and Seaman (2016)
reported that educational institutions adopting elearning methodologies experienced enhanced student
outcomes and higher satisfaction levels (Davies, 2005;
Underwood, 2003; Welsh, 2003). Their comprehensive
survey of over 2,800 colleges and universities indicated
that students benefited from the flexibility and
accessibility of web-based learning, which led to better
academic performance and greater student autonomy.

Table 6: Comparative Analysis of E-learning Effectiveness in Various Countries
Study
Country
Key Findings
Reference
Zhao et al. USA
e-learning can be as effective as Zhao, Y., et al.
(2005).
traditional methods
Allen & Seaman USA
Improved student outcomes and Allen, I. E., & Seaman, J.
(2016)
satisfaction with e-learning
Al-Qahtani & Saudi
Blended e-learning increased Al-Qahtani, A. A. Y., &
Higgins (2013). Arabia
student performance in higher Higgins, S. E.
education
Lim, Morris, & South
Online learning led to higher Lim, D. H., Morris, M. L., &
Kupritz (2007) Korea
student
engagement
and Kupritz, V. W.
participation.

Furthermore, Al-Qahtani and Higgins (2013)
conducted a study in Saudi Arabia, where they found
that a blended e-learning approach significantly
enhanced student performance in higher education
settings (Basak, 2018; Mouratidis, 2021; Saleem,
2022). This study highlighted that combining online
and face-to-face interactions allowed for a more
flexible and enriched learning experience.
In South Korea, Lim, Morris, and Kupritz (2007)
demonstrated that online learning environments
fostered greater student engagement and participation
than traditional classroom settings. Their research
indicated that students were more likely to interact
with course materials and actively participate in
discussions when learning online.
In conclusion, the empirical support from prior
research strongly endorses the implementation of webbased learning models in Islamic Religious Education
(PAI). The evidence suggests that e-learning promotes
better academic outcomes and increases student
interest and independence, making it a viable and
effective method for achieving educational goals in PAI
(Denofrio, 2007; Rubin, 1984; Weber, 2005).

4. CONCLUSION
The research concludes that implementing web-based
learning models (e-learning) in Islamic Religious
Education (PAI) significantly enhances student
engagement and participation. The findings indicate
that e-learning fosters greater learning independence
among students, allowing them to manage their

P
A
G

learning pace and schedule. Additionally, the digital
platform enables access to a broader array of learning
resources, making the subject matter more accessible
and diverse. The dynamic interaction facilitated by elearning tools also promotes a more engaging and
interactive learning environment between teachers
and students.
Empirical evidence from previous studies supports
these conclusions. For instance, a study by Al-Fraihat,
Joy, and Sinclair (2020) found that e-learning
environments
significantly
improve
student
satisfaction and performance by offering flexible and
personalized learning experiences. Similarly, research
by Al-Jarf (2021) highlighted that e-learning platforms
in religious education contexts improved students'
critical thinking and collaborative skills through
interactive and multimedia-rich content. Furthermore,
the study by Hamid et al. (2020) demonstrated that elearning can effectively address the motivational
challenges faced by students, as it provides a
stimulating and engaging way to approach learning
tasks.
In conclusion, integrating web-based learning models
in PAI education aligns with the goals set forth by the
National Education System Law No. 20 of 2003. By
leveraging the advantages of e-learning, educators can
cultivate a more enthusiastic and participatory
learning environment, thereby fostering the
development of students who are faithful, devout, and

possess noble character. This approach not only meets
the academic requirements but also supports the
holistic growth of students in their religious and moral
education.

5. REFERENCE
Abidin, M. Z., Mispani, M., Yusuf, M., Setiawan, A., Wati,
R. I., & Darmayanti, R. (2023). Implementasi
Amaliyah Ahlussunnah Wal Jamaâ€TMah Dalam
Mengatasi Perilaku Amoral Sebagai Upaya
Pembentukan Akhlak Remaja. Assyfa Journal of
Islamic Studies, 1, 51–62.
Adibussholih, M. (2023). Aktualisasi Diri Keagamaan
Dalam Pembentukan Akhlak Di Pondok Pesantren
Al-Qudsi Tulang Bawang. Assyfa Journal of Islamic
Studies, 1.
Adibussholih, M., Subandi, S., Jaenullah, J., & Indrianis, Y.
(2023). Moral Formation: How is religious selfactualization at the Al-Qudsi Tulang Bawang
Islamic Boarding School? Assyfa Journal of Islamic
Studies, 1, 87–98.
Aisyah, I. S., Susilawati, S. A., odi, M. M., Darmayanti, R.,
& Syalsabilla, A. (2024). Langkah cerdas
sinkronisasi Google Scholar. Muhammadiyah
University Press.
Aji, F. B., Nurmalitasari, D., Lestari, A. S. B., &
Muhammad, I. (2023). Comedian Mathematical
Thinking: An Islamic Examination of Inductive,
Deductive, and Analogy Approaches in the
Creation of Stand-Up Comedy Material. Assyfa
Journal of Islamic Studies, 1, 24–30.
Akkapram, P. (2020). The impact of the Sinsai Roo Jai
ton project on the development of local culture
and contemporary performance in northeastern
Thailand. Manusya, 23(3), 430 – 449.
https://doi.org/10.1163/26659077-02303011
Andreev, V. V, Evdokimova, O. K., Gorbunov, V. I., &
Vasilieva, L. N. (2020). Higher engineering
education: Traditions, regular and forced
innovations. Journal of Physics: Conference Series,
1691(1).
https://doi.org/10.1088/17426596/1691/1/012142
Anisah, A. (2023). Implementation Strengthening
Education Character Student School Al-Anwar’s
Foundations Through School Culture. Assyfa
Journal of Islamic Studies, 1, 121–129.
Asmawati, D., Aziz, I., & Wijaya, A. (2024). Fostering
Noble Morals Through Example and Habituation
(Case Study at TPA At-Thususniah). Assyfa Journal
of Islamic Studies, 1, 1–10.
Asror, K., Subandi, S., Jaenullah, J., & Bahri, M. S. (2023).
The Effect of setting up an Irish boarding school
on the rights of Adolescence. Assyfa Journal of
Islamic Studies, 1, 110–120.
Behari-Leak, K. (2020). Toward a borderless,
decolonized, socially just, and inclusive
scholarship of teaching and learning. Teaching
and Learning Inquiry, 8(1), 4 – 23.

https://doi.org/10.20343/TEACHLEARNINQU.8.
1.2
Choirudin, C., Darmayanti, R., Usmiyatun, U., Sugianto,
R., & Ananthaswamy, V. (2021). Mathematics
teacher vs. media development, What are the
learning problems in MTs? AMCA Journal of
Religion and Society, 1, 19–24.
da Silva Santiago, P. V., Darmayanti, R., & Feijão, M. M.
A. (2024). ENSINO DE FRAÇÕES COM
SOFTWARE GEOGEBRA: OBJETIVAÇÃO DAS
FIGURAS GEOMÉTRICAS. Congresso Brasileiro
Interdisciplinar Em CiÃancia e Tecnologiaa, 26–30.
Damrosch, D. (2020). Scriptworlds Lost and Found.
Journal of World Literature, 1(2), 143 – 157.
https://doi.org/10.1163/24056480-00102002
Darmawati, B., Darmayanti, R., & da Silva Santiago, P. V.
(2024). Contemporary Mathematics Learning:
Instagram-based
math
learning
medium
increased elementary school students’ math
literacy. Journal of Teaching and Learning
Mathematics, 2, 142–150.
Darmayanti, R., Choirudin, C., Hadiroh, S., Sumani, S.,
Naim, M. A., & Aidha, A. S. (2024). Pizza Vs. PJBL:
How mathematics learning media improves high
school
students
creative
thinking
on
trigonometric function limits. Assyfa Journal of
Islamic Studies, 1.
Darmayanti, R., Fikri, M., & Rahman, M. A. (2023).
Student learning outcomes will" improve" when
using counting box media. How significant is the
impact of this media? Assyfa Journal of Islamic
Studies, 1.
Darmayanti, R., Hariyadi, A., Kurniawati, W., &
Anggraini, D. (2024). SI-Kepo Workshop: OnlineOffline Scientific Writing Training for Raden
Rahmad Mojosari Vocational School Teachers.
Jurnal Inovasi Dan Pengembangan Hasil
Pengabdian Masyarakat, 1.
Darmayanti, R., Nuryami, N., Sukriyah, Y., Sahara, N.,
Suprayitno, K., Susetyarini, Rr. E., & Baiduri, B.
(2024). Behaviorisme dalam pendidikan [sumber
elektronis] : pembelajaran berbasis stimulusrespon. Penerbit Adab.
Davis, T. (2020). Dual Inheritance, Common Sense, and
the Justification of Religious Belief. In Scientific
Challenges to Common Sense Philosophy. Taylor
and
Francis.
https://doi.org/10.4324/9781351064224-13
Eliseu, S., Lopes, M. M., Ribeiro, J. P., & Oliveira, F.
(2020). Learning and Creativity Through a
Curatorial Practice Using Virtual Reality. Lecture
Notes in Computer Science (Including Subseries
Lecture Notes in Artificial Intelligence and Lecture
Notes in Bioinformatics), 12425 LNCS, 377 – 387.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-60128-7_28
Fajri, A., & Yusuf, M. (2023). Implementation of Tasawuf
Education Imam Al-Ghozali. Assyfa Journal of
Islamic Studies, 2.

Haanurat, A. I. (2024). Problems of Investment Literacy
and Utilization of Security Crowdfunding in
Digital Age Through the Islamic Capital Market.
Assyfa Journal of Multidisciplinary Education, 2,
104–115.
Hamdiati, R., Mispani, M., & Amirudin, A. (2024).
Metode Problem Based Learning Dalam
Meningkatkan Keaktifan Belajar Siswa Pada Mata
Pelajaran PAI Siswa SMP Islam Sirojul Munir AlIhsan Lampung Timur. Assyfa Journal of Islamic
Studies, 2.
Hansen, K. (2020). Apprenticeship in practice
supervision in teacher education: Individual,
relational or in community of practice? A study of
exam texts; [Mesterlære i praksisveiledning i
lærerutdanning: Individuell, relasjonell eller i
praksisfelleskap? En studie av eksamenstekster].
Acta
Didactica
Norden,
14(2).
https://doi.org/10.5617/adno.7925
Hendarto, T., I.P., S., Darmayanti, R., & odi, M. M. (2024).
Sinkronisasi cerdas researchgate. CV. Bildung
Nusantara.
Hendarto, T., Nahdiyah, N., Mas’odi, M., & Darmayanti,
R. (2024). Sinkronisasi media sosial panduan
utama menggunakan google scholar. CV. Bildung
Nusantara.
Hotimah, L. H., Hasyim, U. A. A., & Dewi, Y. A. S. (2024).
Implementation of Islamic Religious Education in
Cultivating Morals in Elementary School Students.
Assyfa Journal of Multidisciplinary Education, 1, 5–
9.
Huerta, R. (2020). Design of letters as a visual
environment to educate in diversity; [El diseño de
letras: Como entorno visual para educar en
diversidad Aprender de letra en la formación del
profesorado]. Artseduca, 25, 5 – 22.
https://doi.org/10.6035/Artseduca.2020.25.1
Humaidi, M. N., Triansyah, F. A., Sugianto, R., & Laila, A.
R. N. (2023). Development of a HOTS-Leveled
Two-Tier Multiple Choice (TTMC) Test to
Measure Student Misconceptions in Islamic
Studies. Assyfa Journal of Islamic Studies, 1, 31–40.
Humammi, H., Syafei, I., & Janah, S. R. (2024). Efektivitas
Penggunaan Teknologi Informasi Dalam Platfrom
Merdeka
Mengajar
Pada
Pembelajaran
Pendidikan Agama Islam di Kabupaten
Pringsewu. Assyfa Journal of Islamic Studies, 2, 6–
23.
Hussain, N., & Xi, W. (2023). Islam and International
Standards of Human Rights: An Analysis of
Domestic Implementation of International
Human Rights in Islamic Culture. Assyfa Journal of
Islamic Studies, 1, 1–12.
Karas, S. I. (2020). Virtual patients as a format for
simulation learning in continuing medical
education (review article); [Виртуальные
пациенты как формат симуляционного
обучения в непрерывном медицинском

P
A
G

образовании (обзор литературы)]. Bulletin of
Siberian Medicine, 19(1), 140 – 149.
https://doi.org/10.20538/1682-0363-2020-1140-149
Kengpol, A., Koohathongsumrit, N., & Meethom, W.
(2020). Time analysis of teaching and learning
method based on LOVE model. Advances in
Intelligent Systems and Computing, 1134 AISC, 528
– 538. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-03040274-7_51
LaDuca, B., Carroll, C., Ausdenmoore, A., & Keen, J.
(2020). Pursuing Social Justice through PlaceBased Community Engagement: Cultivating
Applied Creativity, Transdisciplinarity, and
Reciprocity in Catholic Higher Education.
Christian Higher Education, 19(1–2), 60 – 77.
https://doi.org/10.1080/15363759.2019.16892
04
Listiyanti, G., & Hasyim, U. A. A. (2024). The Role of
Islamic Religious Education Teachers in Fostering
Student Learning Discipline at SMK N 1
Pekalongan. Assyfa Journal of Islamic Studies, 1,
11–18.
Lubis, M. (2024). How is exploring social media’s
potential to promote Islamic understanding in the
digital age? Assyfa Journal of Islamic Studies, 1.
Makhmud, I., Bustomi, A. A., Darmayanti, R., Vedianty, A.
S. A., Amelia, N. D., & Hujjah, S. (2024).
Strengthening PERGUNU’s Prophecy Movement
through Mentoring at the NU Branch Leadership
Level in Pasuruan City. Jurnal Inovasi Dan
Pengembangan Hasil Pengabdian Masyarakat, 2,
16–23.
Mubarok, M. Z., Subandi, M., Yusuf, M., & Darmayanti, R.
(2023). Efforts to improve tajwid learning using
the An-Nahdliyah method in Diniyah students.
Assyfa Journal of Islamic Studies, 1, 99–109.
Nurhakim, M., Darmayanti, R., & Pongsibanne, M. W.
(2024). Indonesian Vs. Thailand: The historicity
of Muhammadiyah’s" founding idea," what is the
vision of Muhammadiyah’s mission? Assyfa
Journal of Islamic Studies, 1.
Nuryami, N., Sukriah, Y., Sahara, N., Eriyanti, R. W.,
Huda, A. M., Suprayitno, K., & Darmayanti, (ed)
Rani. (2024). Metodologi penelitian [sumber
elektronis] :
menguasai
pemilihan
dan
penggunaan metode. CV. Adanu Abimata.
odi, M. M., Mustofa, N. H., Tobroni, T., Widodo, J., &
Darmayanti, (ed) Rani. (2024). Filsafat
pendidikan : hakikat guru, siswa dan Interaksi
edukatif ditinjau dari manajemen pendidikan
digital. CV. Adanu Abimata.
Pandia, W. S. S., & Drew, A. (2023). Identifying and
solving Islamic religious education challenges for
special needs children. Assyfa Journal of Islamic
Studies, 2.
Pandia, W. S. S., Lee, S., & Khan, S. (2024). The
fundamentals of Islamic religious education in

inclusive schools meet special needs children’s
PAI issues. Assyfa Journal of Islamic Studies, 1.
Pandia, W. S. S., Naim, M. A., & Siddique, M. (2023).
Student growth, qualities, and abilities in
developing religious ideals from childhood.
Which approach works? Assyfa Journal of Islamic
Studies, 1.
Prasetyani, W., Hartati, Y., Yasirudin, Y., Sulaiman, E.,
Subing, Z., & Jaenullah, J. (2024). Nilai-Nilai
Pendidikan Akhlak Dalam Kitab Al-Barzanji.
Assyfa Journal of Islamic Studies, 1.
Premawardhena, N. C. (2020). Defying Learning
Traditions: From Teacher-Centred to StudentCentred Foreign Language Education Through
Digital Transformation at Sri Lankan Universities.
Advances in Intelligent Systems and Computing,
916, 229 – 238. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3030-11932-4_23
Risager, K. (2020). Language textbooks: windows to the
world. Language, Culture and Curriculum, 1 – 14.
https://doi.org/10.1080/07908318.2020.17977
67
Safsouf, Y., Mansouri, K., & Poirier, F. (2020). An
analysis to understand the online learners’
success in public higher education in Morocco.
Journal of Information Technology Education:
Research,
19,
113
–
130.
https://doi.org/10.28945/4526
Suharsiwi, S., Lestari, J. T., & Karim, S. (2023). Islamic
content-based learning: Kindergarten illustrated
narrative song" Lulu and Tom". Assyfa Journal of
Islamic Studies, 1.
Sutomo, E., Darmayanti, R., Faishal, (ed) Muhammad
Rafli, Usmiyatun, (ed) Usmiyatun, & S, (ed) M

Syaifuddin. (2024). Instrumen penelitian media
pembelajaran nondigital [sumber elektronis]. Lima
Aksara.
Tiejun, Z., & Linlin, Z. (2020). Research on the
dimensions of art design education in Taiwan
Shih Chien University. Lecture Notes of the
Institute for Computer Sciences, Social-Informatics
and Telecommunications Engineering, LNICST,
339, 351 – 361. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3030-63952-5_30
Wahid, A. K., & Arifin, M. Z. (2024). PAI Teacher
Strategies in Overcoming the Impact of Juvenile
Delinquency Case Study at SMK N 3 Metro. Assyfa
Journal of Islamic Studies, 1, 19–25.
Wicaksana, M. F., Kusumaningsih, D., Suparmin, S.,
Sukarno, S., Saptomo, S. W., Pardyatmoko, P.,
Sudiatmi, T., Muryati, S., Septiari, W. D., &
Darmayanti, R. (2024). Panduan Lengkap
Sinkronisasi ORCID ID Teori dan Aplikasinya. CV.
Bildung Nusantara.
Xiaolin, Z. (2020). Zhu Shenghao as a translator of
Shakespeare; [Чжу Шэнхао — переводчик
Шекспира]. Voprosy Literatury, 4, 204 – 216.
https://doi.org/10.31425/0042-8795-2020-4204-216
Zahroh, U., Rachmawati, N. I., & Darmayanti, R. (2023).
Significance of Collaborative Learning Guidelines
in 21st Century Education on Functional Limits
Material in Madrasah Tsanawiyah. Assyfa Journal
of Islamic Studies, 2, 155–161.