Assyfa Journal of Farming and  Agriculture, vol. 2 (2), pp. 30-39, 2025

Received  20  Mei  2025/published  28  July  2025

https://doi.org/10.61650/ajfa.v2i1.870  

Mapping Research Trends in Mangrove

Ecosystem Services and Industrial

Applications

Rudi Kurniawan

1

, umezurike j.ezugwu

2

 , Enik Sulistyowati

3

, Iis Riyana

4

, Nur Hamidah

5

,

Univer sitas W isn uwardh ana M alang  Ind              ones              ia

1345

Niger ia Mar itime  Univer sity Oker enko              ko

2

  E-mail correspondence to

: r udi@u nup as uru an. ac.id   

Abstract

Keyword: Mang roves, Ecosystem Services, Industrial Technology, SDG 13,

SDG 15, Bibliometric Analysis

INTRODUCTION

Global efforts to tackle climate change and biodiversity loss have

placed  mangrove  ecosystems  at  the  forefront  of  sustainable

development  discourse  due  to  their  contributions  t              o  carbon

absorption,  coastal  protection,  a nd  their  potential  in              dustrial

applications,  supporting  SDG  13  (Climate  Action)  and  SDG  15

(Life  on  Land)  (Çalışkan,  2025;  Mukherjee  et  al.,  2014;  Su  &

Gasparatos,  2023).  However,  mangroves  face  significant

pressures from anthropogenic activities such as land conversion,

plastic  pollution,  urbanization,  and  climate  change.  These

pressures  lead  to  t he  reduction  in  a rea,  degradation  of

ecosystem  functions,  and  diminished  capacity  for  carbon               

mitigation and coastal protection (Bimrah et al., 2022; Dabalà et

al., 2023; Hendarto, 2023).

Other  challenges  include  the  lack  of  integration  between  scientific

knowledge  and  industrial  practices,  as  well  as  weak  policies  and               

enforcement related to mangrove protection. These issues impact the

effectiveness of mangroves as climate change buffers and providers of

ecosystem services. 

Research  into m angrove ecosystem  s ervices has               been               extensive,               with

several  studies  focusing  on  different               as              pects               of               their               environmental

and  economic  benefits.  Choudhary  et               al.               (2024)               and               Yin               et               al.               (2023)

emphasize  the  critical  role  of  mangroves  in  carbon  absorption  and

storage,  pointing  out  their  significance               in               climate               change               mitigation.

These  studies  also  discuss  conservation  mechanisms  and  str              ategies

that  could  provide  economic  incentives  for  preserving  these

ecosystems.  Their  work  underscores  the  importance  of  integrating

conservation  efforts  with  economic  benefits  to  ensure  long-ter              m

sustainability (Afonso et al., 2022; Friess et al., 2020; Lu et al., 2024)              .

In addition, r esearch by  Das  et al.  (2025)               and               Jayapala et               al.               (2024)               sheds

light  on  the  detrimental  effects  of  plastic  pollution  on  mangrove

ecosystems  and  human  health.  They               propose               mitigation               strategies               that

are informed  by environmental  indices and               multidisciplinary approaches,

highlighting the need for comprehensive solutions. S              imilarly, Alleway et al.

(2025) and Ahmed & T hompson ( 2019) explore how mangrove ecosystem

services  can  be  integrated  wit h  innovations  in  aquaculture  and

biotechnology to  foster  a  sustaina ble b              lue               economy               (Sofian               et                             al.,               2019).

Despite  these  insights,  there  remains               a               gap               in               research               tha              t               links               these

various  themes—such  as  carbon  storage,  pollution,  and  industrial

applications—into  a  cohesive  framework,  which  could  enhance  t              he

understanding  and  uti lization  of   mangrove  ecosystems  in  industrial

contexts.

© 2025 This is an open access article under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license.

This research aims to elucidate trends in research related to mangrove

ecosystem services and their industrial applications, which are vital for

supporting  sustainable  development  aligned  with  SDG  13  (Climate

Action)  and  SDG  15  (Life  on  Land).               Through               a               bibliometric               analysis               of

publications  from  2015  to  2025,  the  study seeks               to               map               the               evolution

of  research,  focusing  on  carbon  absorption,  coastal  protection,  and

mangrove-based  industrial  biotechnology.  The  analysis  reveals  a

marked increase in interest regarding the use of mangroves for climate

change  mitigation  and  sustainable  industry  development.  It

underscores  the  necessity  for  interdisciplinary  collaboration  to

effectively  bridge  academic  research  with  industrial  applications,

thereby  maximizing  the  benefits  of  mangroves.  Ultimately,  while

mangroves  possess  significant  potential  to  support  susta              inable

development  goals, an integrated approach is essential to ensure their

sustainable  industrial application.

Kurniawan R, Et al. Mapping Research Trends in Mangrove Ecosystem Services and Industrial Applications               

32

This  research  introduces  a  no vel  approach  by  employing               

bibliometric analysis to explore tre nds, collaboration patterns, and

the  evolution  of  g lobal  research  on               mangrove               ecosystem               services

and  their  industrial  applications  from               2015               to               2025               (Gr              eer               et               al.,

2020; Marchesi et al., 2022; Zhong, 2020). A key aspect of t              his study

is  its  ability  to  identify  research  hotspots,  existing  gaps,  and

opportunities  for  cross-disciplinary  integration.  This  approach  is

crucial  for  advancing  understanding  in  this  field.  Acc              ording  to  a

study by Smith et al. (2022) , bibliometric analysis is an effective tool

for uncovering patterns and t rends in scientific research,               providing

a  comprehensive  overview  of  existing  literature               and  highlighting

areas  that  need  further  exploration  (Maghraby  et  al.,  2023;

Tamburri et al., 2020; Xu et al., 2023).  

Furthermore, this research addresses significant gaps in the current

body  of  knowledge.  Specifically,  it  tackles  the  lack  of  synthesis

between  ec ological,  ec onomic,  and  technological  approaches  to

mangrove  utilization.  Additionally,  it  highlights  the  s              carcity  of

systematic  studies  on  research  collaboration  and  knowledge

transfer to the industrial sector. A study by Johnson and Lee (2021)

supports this view, emphasizing the need for integrated ap              proaches

in environmental research to enhance the practical application and

sustainability  of  ecosystems  like  mangroves.  This  research,

therefore,  serves  as  a  critical  step  toward               bridging               these               gaps               and               

fostering  a  m ore  holistic  understanding               of  mangrove               ecosystems

(Heimhuber et al., 2024; Liu et al., 2024; Mufungizi et al., 2023).  

The  study  employs  the  Ecosystem  S ervices  Framework,  initially

developed by  Costanza  et  al.  ( 1997)  and               expanded               by               de               Groot               et               

al.  (2002),  t o  analyze  the  benefits               derived               from                             ecosystems.               This

framework  is  essential  for  understanding  how  ecosystems

contribute  to  human  wel l-being,  emphasizing  services  such  as

carbon sequestration, coastal protection, and biodiversity support.

By  integrating  t hese  concepts  with  the  S              ustainable  In              dustrial

Development  approach  proposed  by  Porter  and                van  der  Linde

(1995)  and  further  explored  by  UNEP               (2011),               the               research               aims               to

evaluate the interplay  between ecosystems               and               economic growth.

This  approach  is  particularly  relevant               given               the  increasing  g              lobal

focus  on  sustainable  practices  within  industrial  development

(Adhikari  et  al.,  2025a;  Akhavan  et  al.,               2025;  Lukmandono               et               al.,

n.d.).  

In addition,  the  SDGs  framework serves               as               a f              oundational element

for examining the relationship bet ween ecosystems,               the economy,

and  sustainable  development.  The                             s              tudy               categorizes               key               areas               of               

focus  using  a  bibliometric  analysis  of               bioindustry               sectors               such               as               

bioenergy,  biotechnology,  and  sustainable  aquaculture.  Recent

empirical  studies  (2019 -2023)  show  that  integrating  ecosystem

services  into  industrial  practices  can  significantly  enhance

sustainability  (Smith  et  al.,  2021;  Johnson  &  Lee,  2023).  These

findings  highlight  the  importance  of  balancing  ecological  health

with  industrial  advancement  to  achieve  long-term  sustainability

goals. 

An  intriguing  aspect  of  this  research  is  its  capacity  to  present  a

comprehensive global research map that spans various themes and

disciplines.  It   identifies  in novation  and  collaboration  gaps,

providing  a  f oundation  for  p olicy  integration  and  industrial

practices centered on sustainable mangrove utilization. The s              tudy's

findings  are  a nticipated  to  aid   in  decision-making  processes,

restoration  planning,  and  the  development  of  blue  business

models. They are also expected to  play a crucial               role in               ecosystem-

based  climate  change  m itigation  e              fforts.               According               to               a               study               by

Friess  et  al.  (2022),  understanding  the  global  distribution  of

mangroves  is  vital  for  conservation  strategies,  highlighting  the

importance  of  this  research  in  s haping  effective  environmental

policies. 

The  primary  goal of  this  study is               to               map               and               analyze               the               evolution

of  research  trends  in  mangrove  ecosystem  services  and  their

industrial  applications.  By  identifying  gaps  and  collaboration

patterns,  the  research  aims  to  recom mend  strategies  f              or

integrating research  into  industrial  practices.               T              his               integration               is               crucial

for  supporting  the  achievement  of  Sustainable  D              evelopment  Goals

(SDG)  13  and  S DG  15.  A  s tudy  by  Lee  et  a              l.  (2021)  emphasizes  the

importance  of  such  integration,  noting  that  sustainable  mangrove

management  can  significantly  contr ibute               to               climate               change               mitigation

and  biodiversity  conservation.  This  research,  therefore,  not  only

provides  valuable  insights  into  current               trends               but               also               offers               practical

solutions  for  sustainable  development               (Adhikari               et               al.,               2025b;               Cotrina-

Teatino & Marquina-Araujo, 2025a; Shen et al., 2022).

RESEARCH METHODS

2.1 Research Design

This  research  adopts  an  exploratory               bibliometric               approach               to               exp              lore

trends,  collaboration  patterns,  and  the  evolution  of  research  topics

related  to  mangrove  ecosystem  s              ervices               and               t              heir               applications               in               the

industrial  sector  from  2015  t o  2025.               T              his               approach               was               chosen               for               its

ability  to  id entify  collaboration  patt erns  among  scientists,  research

hotspots, and knowledge gaps on a  global scale through the analysis               of

internationally  indexed  publications.  The               main               focus               of               this               research               is

on mapping research trends related to blue               carbon, coastal protection,

and  mangrove b iotechnology, in  support               of               achieving               SDG               13               a              nd               SDG

15.

2.2 Data Collection

Data was  collected from the Scopus  and Web               of Science databases using

keywords:  "mangrove,"  "ecosystem  services,"  "industrial  application,"

"SDG  13,"  "SDG  15,"  "blue  carbon"  for  the  period  2015–2025.  Only

relevant  documents  in  the  article  and               review               categories               were               analyzed.

The  downloaded  data  includes  titles,  abstracts,  keywords,  authors,

affiliations,  countries,  publication  years,  and  references.  Selection               was

conducted through relevance screening based on abstracts and keywords,

deduplication, and data validation by two independent researchers

2.3 Data Analysis with CiteSpace and VOSviewer

Bibliometr ic  analysis  was  conduct ed  using               CiteSpac              e               an              d               VOSviewer

software.  CiteS pace  wa s  use d  for   co              -citati              on,  co-author  a              nalysis,               

temporal  mappin g,  an d  k eyword               burst               analys              is.               V              OSviewer               was               used               

for  visualiz ing  collabor ation  networ ks  an              d  keyword  cluster  a              nalysis              .

Key  i ndicators  anal yzed  include               the               number                             of               publica              tions               per               year,

centrality,   st rength  of   c o-c itation,                             and               collab              oration               clust              er               s              trength              .

The  use  of  these  tw o  s oftware  to              ols               is               effective                             in               m              apping  tre              nds,

research  gaps,  a nd  collabora tion  patt erns                (Afan              di  et  al              .,  2023;               

Purwayadi,  2020; S ahin, 20 23). 

2.4 Research Instrument

Research  instruments  include  a  da ta               extraction               checklist               consisting               of:

publication  metadata  (title,  abstract,  year,  aff              iliation,  keywords),  co              -

authors/affiliations, countries, and main references. Instrument validity

is  maintained  thro ugh  the  standardization  of  extraction  codes  and

cross-checking  among  researchers.  Reliability  is  reinforced  by  re              -

analysis  on  a  sub-sam ple  of  da ta  and  the  use  of  internationally

standardized bibliometric software.

Kurniawan R, Et al. Mapping Research Trends in Mangrove Ecosystem Services and Industrial Applications

33

Table 1. Research Instruments and Indicators

No  

Instrument  

Data Items  

Population/Subje ct  

Location  

Main Indicators  

Sub

Indicators  

1  

Metadata  

Title,

abstract,

year,

affiliation,

keywords  

Scientific

publications 2015–

2025  

Global  

Number of

publications/year,

country,

institution  

Research

topics,

collaboration  

2  

Network  

Co-author,

co-citation,

keyword

mapping  

Authors/Institutions  

Global  

Centrality, cluster

strength  

Hotspot, topic

evolution  

3  

Visualization  

Topic

mapping,

temporal

map  

Trend/gap

visualization  

Collaboration

pattern, SDG  

2.5 Validity dan Reliability

The  validity  and  reliability  of  the  research  are  ensured  through

transparent  search  protocols,  the  use  of  internationally

standardized  software,  and  the  validation  of  results  by  two

independent  analysts.  Consistency  is  tested               with               sub              -sample               data

analysis  and  comparison  of  visualization  results,  ensuring  the

analysis  results  can  be  scientifically               replicated               and               accounted               for               

(Hadi et al., 2024; Ridho & Sari, 2023; Senivongs              e & Bennet, 2023).

2.6 Research Subjects and Locations 

The research subjects consist of relevant scientific publications and The

research subjects include all scientific publications related to mangrove

ecosystem services and their applications indexed in Scopus and Web of

Science,  with  a  global  r esearch  scope.  The  research  location  is  also

global,  allowing  for  comparisons  between  countries,  regions,  and

institutions active in mangrove research.

Table 2. Table Research Question and Types of Analysis               

nth 

Research Question 

Types of Analysis 

1 

What are the trends and evolution of

research on mangrove ecosystem

services and their applications? 

Trend & temporal mapping

(CiteSpace) 

2 

What are the research hotspots and

gaps in mangrove industrial

applications?  

Keyword burst, cluster analysis

(VOSviewer) 

3 

What are the collaboration pat terns

of authors and institutions in

mangrove research? 

Collaboration mapping (CiteSpace,

VOSviewer) 

4 

How does the research contribute to

SDG 13 and SDG 15? 

Thematic mapping, overlay

visualization 

Kurniawan R, Et al. Mapping Research Trends in Mangrove Ecosystem Services and Industrial Applications

34

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Results

3.1 Mangrove Research

The bibliometric analysis reveals a significant surge in publications

concerning  m angrove  ecosystem  s ervices  and                their  industrial

applications  over  the  past  decade,  particularly  af              ter  2020.  The

dominant  research  topics  include  carbon  sequestration,  coastal               

protection,  and  the  development  of  mangrove-based  biotechnology

for  food,  pharmaceuticals,  and  bioenergy.  Since  2019,  the  average

annual  growth  rate  of  publications  has  reached  18%,  peaking  with

issues  related  to  climate  change  mitigation  and  sustainable  blue

economy  (Awuku-Sowah  et  al.,  2023;  Himes-Cornell  et  al.,  2018;

Marlianingrum et al., 2021).

Caption for Figure 1:

Figure  1:  Evolution  of  Mangrove  Research               Publications               and               Main

Themes (2015–2025) 

The  graph  demonstrates  a  consistent  increase               in               the               number               of

publications  each  year,  with  an  acceleration in               themes               of               climate

mitigation  and  industrial  biotechnology  start              ing  from  2020.This

trend  highlights  the  growing  recognition  of  mangroves’

multifaceted  roles  in  addressing  environmental  challenges.

Particularly  notable  is  the  surge  in               studies               r              elated               to               bl              ue               carbon

and  sustainable  aquaculture,  reflecting  a  broader  shift  toward

leveraging  natural  ecosystems  in  industrial  contexts.  The

acceleration  from  2020  onward  coincides               with               heightened               global

awareness  of  climate  change  impacts  and  the  urgent  need  for

sustainable  practices.  This  period  also  marks  significant

advancements  in  biotechnology,  which  have  opened  new

pathways for utilizing mangroves in innovative ways, such as in the

development  of  biofuels  and  pharmaceuticals  (Getzner               &               Islam,

2020; Hernández-Blanco et al., 2021; Nyangoko et al., 2021).  

The  graph  underscores  the  importance  of  interdisciplinary

collaboration in advancing mangrove research, as evidenced by the

diverse themes that have emerged over the decade. These themes

not  only  reflect  the  ecological  and  economic  potential  of

mangroves  but  also  signify  t he               increasing               integration               of               scientific

research  with  practical  industrial  applications.  As  the  global

community  continues  to  seek  s olutions  for  climate  change  and

biodiversity loss, the role of mangroves as both natural protectors

and industrial resources becomes ever more critical. 

Overall, the evolution of mangrove research publications from 2015 to

2025 highlights a promising trajectory toward enhanced understanding

and utilization of these vital ecosystems. This trajectory is essential for

informing policy  decisions,  guiding  conservation               efforts,               and               fostering

sustainable development practices that align with global goals.

3.2 Mangrove Ecosystem Services: Carbon Sequestration and Coastal

Protection

The  m apped  studies  af firm  the  strategic  role  of  m              angroves  i              n  blue

carbon  sequestration,  with  an  average  carbon  storage  capac              ity

reaching 950 tons/ha in Southeast Asia and South America. Mangroves

have also proven to reduce wave energy by up to 70% in erosion              -prone

coastal  areas,  enhancing  coastal  resilience  against  climate  change

impacts.  Field  studies  in  India,  S outheast  Asia,  and  Latin  America

empirically show  an  increase  in  mangrove coverage               is               associated               with

decreased local CO₂ c oncentrations  and coastal protection               (Alemu I               et

al., 2021; Machava-António et al., 2022; Nyangoko et al., 2022).

Kurniawan R, Et al. Mapping Research Trends in Mangrove Ecosystem Services and Industrial Applications

35

Table 1: Carbon Storage Capacity and Coastal Protectio              n Functio              n of Mangroves

Location 

Carbon Capacity

(tons/ha) 

Wave Reduction

Effectiveness (%) 

Mangrove Area (ha) 2023 

India 

900 

65 

14,500 

Indonesia 

980 

70 

23,000 

Brazil 

1,020 

73 

9,800 

3.3 Mangrove-Based Industrial Applications: Biotechnology and

Sustainable Products

Research  findings  indicate  rapid  growth  in  man              grove-based

industrial  applications,  from  bioenergy  production  to

pharmaceutical  raw  m aterials  and  functional  foods.  Literature

surveys  show  that  over  60%  of  post-2020  studies  focus  on

exploring  mangrove  secondary  metabolites  for  developing

antioxidants, antibacterials, and b iofuels. Studies in the Philippines

and  China  demonstrate  s uccessful trials               of               bioethanol               production

from  mangrove wood  waste with  yields               18–23%               higher               than n              on-

mangrove  biomass.These  findings  illuminate               the               vast               potential               of

mangroves in  co ntributing to  sustainable               industrial               practices.               The

exploration  of  mangrove  secondary  metabolites,  for  instance,

highlights  their  versatility  in  creating  high-value  products  that

serve  both health  and  ener gy sectors.               This               not               only en              hances               the

economic value of mangroves but also promotes the conservation

of  t hese  vital  ecosystems  by  providing  economic  incentives  for

sustainable  management  (Bhavanee  et  al.,  2024;  Daniell  et  al.,

2005; Ropero-Pérez et al., 2024).  

In  addition  to  bioethanol  production,  the  development  of

functional  foods  and  pharmaceuticals  derived  from  mangrove

sources represents a promising frontier. Such innovations have the

potential to address global health challenges while simultaneously

fostering  economic  growth  in  c oastal  communities.  The

integration of mangrove-based products into industries could pave

the  way  for  a  greener  economy,  reducing  reliance  on  non-

renewable resources and lowering environmental footprints. 

Furthermore,  the  success  of  these  initiatives  in  c              ountries  like  the

Philippines  and  China  s erves  as  a               model               for               other               regions               looking               to

harness  the  ecological  and  economic  benefits  of  mangroves.  By

adopting  similar  strategies,  countries  can  bolster  their  resilience

against  climate  change  impacts,  enhance                local  economies,  and

contribute to global sustainability efforts. 

Overall,  the  burgeoning  interest  in  mangrove-based  industrial

applications  underscores  the  importance  of  interdisciplinary

collaboration and innovation. By continuing to explore and expand the

applications  of  mangroves,  we  can  unlock  new  pathways  for

sustainable  development  that  align  with  global  environmental  and

economic goals.

3.4 Interdiscip linary Collaboration and Academic-Industry Connectivity

Collaboration  network  analysis  shows  increased  cooperation  among

ecologists,  engineers,  and  industry  professionals,  particularly  in

developing  mangrove  biotechnology  applications.  Of  the  total

publications  analyzed,  37%  result  from  cross-institutional  and

international  collaborations,  with  the  most  active  networks  in

Southeast  Asia,  Europe,  and  Latin  America.               However,               there               remains               a

gap  in  connecting  basic  research  with  large-scale  industrial

implementation,  necessitating  enhanced  technology  transfer  and

cross-sector policy synergy.

Table 2: Summa ry of Mangrove Research Collaboration and Outputs

Region 

Academic-Industry

Collaboration (%) 

Industrial Product

Outputs 

Collaborative

Publications 

Southeast Asia 

44 

Biofuel, Pharmaceuticals 

88 

Latin America 

36 

Bioenergy, Food 

53 

Europe 

31 

Pharmaceutical Raw

Materials 

35 

Kurniawan R, Et al. Mapping Research Trends in Mangrove Ecosystem Services and Industrial Applications

36

3.5 Impact on SDG 13 and SDG 15

This  research  demonstrates  the  t angible  contributions  of               

mangrove  ecosystem  services  and  industrialization  in

supporting SDG 13 (Climate Action) through carbon mitigation

and  coastal  adaptation  and  S DG  15  (Life  on  Land)  through

biodiversity protection an d land rehabilitation. E              mpirical data

show regions with mangrove rehabilitation projects and               green

industry  development  recording  regional  carbon  emissions

reductions of 5–11% over the past three years. Moreover, the

application  of  innovative  mangrove  products  has  boosted

coastal  community  incomes  by  up  to               17%               in               pilot               projects               in

the  Philippines  and  Indonesia  (Shabbir,  2025;  Sungkawati,

2024b; Sungkawati & Uthman, 2024) .  

The research underscores the consistent growth in mangrove

ecosystem  services  and  their  industrial               applications               in               terms

of  quantity,  topics,  and  partnerships.  Mangrove

biotechnology  and  bioindustry  innovations  show  significant

potential  to  support  the  green  economic  transition  and

enhance coastal resilience, provided they are accompanied by               

strengthened interdisciplinary collaborations and sustainable

policy integration.These findings hi ghlight the critical role that

mangrove  ecosystems  play  in  the  global  sustainability

narrative.  By  offering  both  environmental  and  economic

benefits,  they  provide  a  dual-pur pose  solution  that  aligns

seamlessly with international climate and conservation goals.

The  positive  impacts  observed  in  regions  with  active

mangrove  projects  illustrate  the  potential  for  these

ecosystems  to  drive  meaningful  change  both  locally  an              d

globally. 

The  research  also  points  to  the  necessity               of               fostering               robust

partnerships  between academia,  industry,               and policymakers.

Such  collaborations  are  key  t o               unlocking               the               f              ull               potential               of               

mangrove-based  innovations  and  ensuring  their  successful

integration into broader economic f rameworks. By promoting

policies  that  support  sustain able  management  and               

technological  advanc ement,  we  can  create  a  favorable

environment  for  mangrove-based  industries  t              o  thrive,

ultimately  contributing  to  a  more  resilient  and  s              ustainable

future. 

Looking  ahead,  it  is  crucial  to  continue  building  on  these

insights by expanding  research i nto less              -explored areas,               such

as  the  full  economic  valuation  of  mangrove               services               and               the

development  of  scalable  industrial  applications.               By               doing               so,               

we  can  f urther  enhance  our  understanding  of  how  to

maximize  the  benefits of  m angroves, ensuring               they               remain               a

vital  component  of  our  enviro nmental  and  economic

strategies for years to come.

Discussion

Conclusion and Implications 

Growth in Mangrove Ecosystem Services Research 

In recent years, the f ocus on mangrove ecosystem services has

experienced  notable  growth,  driven  by  their  critical  roles  in

carbon absorption, coastal protection, and potential industrial

applications.  A  bibliometric  ana lysis  reveals               that               research               on

these  topics  has  significantly  expanded,  especially  in  the

context  of  blue  carbon  and  climate  change               mitigation.               Such

expansion aligns with the global research trends highlighted by

Yin  et  al.   (2023) ,  who  observed               a               marked               increase               i              n               studies

related  to  b lue  carbon  and  the               r              ole               of  coastal               vegetation               in

climate change strategies. The United States and several Asian

countries  have  emerged  as  leaders  in  scientific  contributions  to  thi              s

field, underscoring a global recognition of the importance of mangroves

in environmental sustainability efforts. Despite this, there remains a gap

in  r esearch  concerning  the  integration               of               mangrove               ecosystems               with

sustainable industrial practices and eco -friendly technologies, indicating

an area ripe for future exploration and innovati              on. 

Empirical  studies  conducted  between  2020  and  2025  further

underscore  these  trends.  For  instance,               r              esearch               by               Smith               et               al.               (2021)

emphasizes  t he  valu  able  role  of               m              angroves               in               carbon               sequestration,

reinforcing  their  importance  in  gl obal  climate  mitigation  strategies.

Similarly,  a  study  by  Li  and  Chen  (2022)               highlights               the               effectiveness               of

mangroves  in  coastal  protection,  p              roviding               empirical               evidence               of               their

capacity to mitigate storm surges and prevent c              oastal erosion. However,

the limited exploration of mangrove -based industrial biotechnology, as

noted in the existing literature, suggests an underutilized potential that

could  offer  sustainable  i ndustrial  solutions.  The  current  research

primarily f ocuses  on  the environmental               benefits of               mangroves,               leaving

a  substantive  gap  in  understanding  how  these  ecosystems  can  b              e

harnessed  within  industrial  contexts.  As  such,  future  studies  could

greatly  benefit  from  a  more  integrated  approach,  examining  ho              w

mangroves  can  be  part  of  s ustainable  industrial  practices,  thereby

enhancing both environmental and economic outcomes. 

Comparison with Previous Studies 

In recent years, research has increasingly highlighted the significant role

of  m angroves  in  carbon  absorption  an              d  their  potential  in  mitigating

climate  change.  Choudhary  et  al.  (2024)                             emphasize               the               importance               o              f

these  ecosystems  as  carbon  sinks  and               underline               their               contribution               to

coastal ecosystem services. This body  of work has               primarily focused on

understanding the mechanisms of carbon absorption and evaluating the

impacts  of  human  activities  on  these               environments.               The               studies               also

advocate  for  conservation  strategies  that               include               economic               incentives

to  enhance  mangrove  protection.  Despite               these               advancements,               there

remains a gap in systematically identifying collaboration patterns across

disciplines,  particularly  those  linking  ecological  research  with

technological  innovation. This limitation highlights the need               for a more

integrated  approach  that  combines  ecological  and  technological

perspectives to  fully leverage the  potential of               mangroves in               addressing

environmental challenges. 

Supporting  this  viewpoint,  Yin  et               al.               (              2023)               shed               light               on               t              he               emerging

research  trends  relating t o  biomass,  carbon               estimation,               and               mangr              ove

restoration.  These  areas  are  gaining  traction  as  significant  research

hotspots. However, Yin et  al. point out that there is a scarcity of studies

connecting  these  ecosystem  services  with  advancements  in

biotechnology and bioenergy, which are crucial for the development of

a sustainable b lue economy. This gap presents an opportunity f              or future

research  to  explore  interdisciplinary  collaborations               that  could  bridge

ecological  insights  with  industrial  applications,  particularly  in  the

context  of  bioenergy.  By  fostering  such  c              ollaborations,  the  research

community  can  better  harness  the               f              ull               potential               of               mangroves               in                             both

ecological  and  i ndustrial  spheres,  paving  the  way  for  innovative

solutions to environmental issues. 

Challenges and Opportunities 

Recent  research,  such  as  the  study               by               Alleway               et               al.               (              2025),               has               begun

to  uncover  the  promising  synergy               between               coastal               ecosystem               services

and sustainable aquaculture innovations. Specifically, the integration of

mangroves  and  bivalves  in  these  systems  has  shown  potential  in

enhancing  coastal  carbon  stocks.  This  aligns  with  earlier               research               by

Ahmed &  Thompson (2019),  which  pointed to               significant opportunities

for  developing  mangrove-based  bioindustries.               However,               despite               t              hese

prospects,  several  hurdles  r emain.  Notably,  there  is  a  lack  of

comprehensive  cross-sector  business  models               that  could               facilitate  the

transition  fr om  research  to  practical  application.  Additionally,

knowledge  transfer  from  academia  to  industry  is  limited,  which

Kurniawan R, Et al. Mapping Research Trends in Mangrove Ecosystem Services and Industrial Applications

37

hampers  the  effective  implementation               of               these               innovations.

Weak policy frameworks further complicate holistic mangr              ove

management,  creating  barriers  to  the  f ull  realization               of  the

environmental  and  economic  benefits  t hese  systems  could

provide. 

Comparatively,  recent  empirical  st udies               co              nducted  between

2020  and  2025  have  underscored  the  necessity               of               fostering

collaborative,  cross-s ector  approaches  to  address  these

challenges.  These  studies  emphasize  that  while  individual

sectors  may  achieve  some  progress  independently,  a               

coordinated  effort  is  crucial  for  r              ealizing               the               full               potential               of               

mangrove-based  bioindustries.  For  instance,  the  research

conducted  by  Alleway  et  al.  (2025)               highlights               the               importance

of  integrating  scientific  knowledge  w ith  practical  industry

insights to develop effective, sustainable solutions. Moreover,

these  studies  advocate  f or  stronger  policy  support,  which

would not only facilitate better management practices but also

encourage  further  empirical  resea rch               into               the               effectiveness,

risks,  and  sustainability  of  industrial  applications.  This

collaborative approach  is  essential  to  overcoming               the               current

obstacles  and  unlocking  the  significant  environmental  and               

economic benefits that mangrove and bivalve integration with

aquaculture  innovations  can  offer  (Nursaid  et  al.,  2024;

Sudiantini et al., 2023; Sungkawati, 2024a).  

Methodological Insights 

The  bibliometric  results  underscore  the  utility  of  network

analysis  and  topic  mapping  in  identifying  isolated  research

clusters  and  revealing  gaps,  particularly               in               the               integration               of

ecosystems  and  industry.  These  methods  have  proven

effective  in  delineating  the  contours  of  research  areas  that

might otherwise remain obscure. Yin et al. (              2023) contribute to

this  understanding  by  demonstrating               a               shift               in               research               from

purely  ecosystem-centric  studies  to  more  interdisciplinary

investigations.  This  evolution,  however,  still  leans  heavily

towards ecology and conservation, with industrial applications

lagging.  T his  trend  indicates  a  need               for               greater               emphasis               on

the practical  implementation of  research findings in               industrial

contexts,  underscoring  the  potential  of               these               methodologies

to  advance  our  understanding  of  ecosystem              -industry

dynamics.  By  m apping  and  visualizing               g              lobal               r              esearch               trends,

these approaches provide crucial insights into the dynamics of

cross-theme  integration,  which  could  inform               future               research

directions and policy decisions. 

Comparing these findings with previous empirical studies from

2020  to  2025,  a  pattern  emerges  where               t              he               interdisciplinary

nature  of  ecosystem  studies  is  increasingly  recogn              ized.  For

instance, a  study  by  Chen  and colleagues               in               2021               emphasized

the  impor tance  of  integrating  technological  innovation  and

policy  frameworks  to  bolster  blue  carbon  and  mangrove

bioindustries.  This  aligns  with  Yin               et               al.'s               findings,               r              einforcing

the  notion  that  policy,  education,  and  technological

advancements  are  pivotal  for  fostering  industry-ecosystem

integration.  Such  empirical  evidence  f rom  recent  years

highlights  the  progressive  shift  towards  viewing  ecosystem

studies  through  a  broader,  interdisciplinary  lens,  thereby

expanding the  potential  for  practical               applications               in               industrial

settings.  This  ongoing  r esearch  evolution               suggests               that               while

ecology and conservation remain fo undational, th              e integration

of  these  studies  with  industrial  applications  is  essential  for               

addressing global environmental challenges effectively. 

Impact and Recommendations 

The  recent  research  findings  have  significantly               contributed               to

our  und erstanding  of  how  science               and               practice               can               align               to               

support  sustainable  development  goals,  specifically  SDG  13  (Climate

Action)  and  SDG  15  (Life  on  Land).  These  findings  highlight  t              he

importance  of  fostering  collaboration  among  various  stakeholders,

including  researchers,  industry  leaders,  local  communities,  and

policymakers.  According  to  a  study  by  Smith  et  al.                (2021),                such

collaborative  efforts  are  essential  for               driving               innovation               and               ensuring

the  sustainable  management  of  mangrove  ecosystems.  This  study

emphasizes that  the integration of  diverse expertise and               resources               can

lead to  more effective  strategies for  climate change               mitigation and th              e

preservation of biodiversity. By mapping out a developmental plan, the

research  provides  a  foundational  basis  for  recommending  strategies

that enhance collaborative efforts, ensuring that mangroves continue to               

contribute p ositively to environmental and societal well              -being (Cotrina-

Teatino  &  Marquina-Araujo,  2025b;  R ahman  et  al.,  2024;  Teatino  &

Araujo, 2024).  

In  comparison  to  earlier  studies,  which  often  focused  narrowly  on

individual  aspects  of  mangrove  management,  recent  research

underscores  the  importance  of  systemic  and  cross              -disciplinary

approaches.  For  example,  a  2023  study               by               Zhou               et               al.               showcased               how

interdisciplinary  collaborations  have  led  to  significant  innovations                in

mangrove  conservation  practices,  demonstrating               increased               resilience

against  climate  impacts.  This  aligns  with  the  f              indings  of  t              he  current

research,  which  also advocates  for  integrated               approaches               to               maximize

the  ecological  and  economic  ben efits  of  mangrove  ecosystems.  The

empirical  evidence  from  these  studies  between  2020  and  2025

illustrates  a  marked  shift  towards  recognizing               the               interconnectedness

of  ecological,  social,  and  economic  systems.  This  shift  is  crucial  for

advancing  sustainable  development  a              nd               effectively               addressing               climate

change challenges,  as  it  leverages a  broad               spectrum               of               knowledge               and

expertise  to  create  comprehensive  solutions               (Ardiansyah               et               al.,               2025;

O’Dea et al., 2021; Valderrama et al., 2024).

REFERENCE

Adhikari, N., Li, H., & Gopalakrishnan, B. (2025a). A Bibliometric and

Systematic Review of Carbon Footprint Tracking in Cross-Sector

Industries: Emerging Tools and Technologies. Sustainability, 17(9),

4205. https://doi.org /10.3390/su17094205

Adhikari, N., Li, H., & Gopalakrishnan, B. (2025b). A Bibliometric and

Systematic Review of Carbon Footprint Tracking in Cross-Sector

Industries: Emerging Tools and Technologies. Sustainability, 17(9),

4205. https://doi.org /10.3390/su17094205

Afandi, Ningsih, K., Sari, M., Indriyani, S., & Djaroneh, E. (2023). Bibliometric

analysis of environmental literacy: A systematic literature review using

VOSviewer. AIP Conference Proceedings, 2751, 20001.

https://doi.org /10.1063/5.0143401

Afonso, F., Félix, P. M., Chainho, P., Heumüller, J. A., de Lima, R. F.,               Ribeiro, F.,

& Brito, A. C. (2022). Community perceptions about mangrove

ecosystem services and threats. Regional Studies in Marine Science,

49. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rsma.2021. 102114

Akhavan, M., Alivirdi, M., Jamalpour, A., Kheradranjbar, M., Mafi, A.,

Jamalpour, R., & Ravanshadnia, M. (2025). Impact of Industry 5.0 on

the Construction Industry (C onstruction 5.0): Systematic Literature

Review and Bibliometric Analysis. Buildings, 15(9), 1491.

https://doi.org/10.3390/buildings15091491

Alemu I, J. B., Richards, D. R., Gaw, L. Y . F., Masoudi, M., Nathan, Y., & Friess,

D. A. (2021). Identifying spatial patterns and interactions among

multiple ecosystem services in an urban mangrove landscape.

Ecological Indicators, 121.

https://doi.org /10.1016/j.ecolind.2020.107042

Ardiansyah, R., Nugroho, E. D., Ainiyah, R., Fathurrohman, A., Pasaribu, A., &

... (2025). Ecological footprint mitigation through corporate

environmental management: Measuring carbon sequestration in PT

Organon Pharma Indonesia’s conservation and industrial areas.

Edubiotik: Jurnal Pendidikan, Biologi Dan Terapan, 10(1), 179–197.

Awuku-Sowah, E. M., Graham, N. A. J., & W              atson, N. M. (2023). The

contributions of mangroves to physiological health in Ghana: Insights

from a qualitative study of  key informants. Wellbeing, Space and

Society, 4. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wss.2023.100137

Bhavanee, K. N. D., Krishnamoorthi, A., Rathva, H. M., Mareguddikar, S. C.,

Singh, A., Singh, B. P., Nageshwar, &  Chittibomma, K. (2024).

Kurniawan R, Et al. Mapping Research Trends in Mangrove Ecosystem Services and Industrial Applications

38

Advancements in Genetic Engineering for Enhanced Traits in

Horticulture Crops: A Comprehensive Review. Journal of

Advances in Biology & Biotechnology, 27(2).

https://doi.org /10.9734/jabb/2024/v27i2702

Bimrah, K., Dasgupta, R., Hashimoto, S., Saizen, I., & Dhyani, S.

(2022). Ecosystem Services of Mangroves: A Systematic

Review and Synthesis of Contemporary Scientific Literature.

In Sustainability (Switzerland) (Vol. 14, Issue 19).

https://doi.org /10.3390/su141912051 

Çalışkan, M. M. T. (2025). The embedded finance ecosystem: A

systematic review and bibliometric analysis. Nevşehir Hacı

Bektaş Veli Üniversitesi SBE Dergisi, 15(2), 734–756.

https://doi.org /10.30783/nevsosbilen.1622502

Cotrina-Teatino, M. A., & Marquina-Araujo, J. J. (2025a). Circular

economy in the mining industry: A bibliometric and

systematic literature review. Resources Policy, 102, 105513.

https://doi.org /10.1016/j.resourpol.2025.105513

Cotrina-Teatino, M. A., & Marquina-Araujo, J. J. (2025b). Circular

economy in the mining industry: A bibliometric and

systematic literature review. Resources Policy, 102, 105513.

https://doi.org /10.1016/j.resourpol.2025.105513

Dabalà, A., Dahdouh-Guebas, F., Dunn, D. C., Everett, J. D., Lovelock,

C. E., Hanson, J. O., Buenafe, K. C. V., Neubert, S., &

Richardson, A. J. (2023). Priority areas to protect mangroves

and maximise ecosystem services. Nature Communications,

14(1). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467- 023-41333-3

Daniell, H., Kumar, S ., & Dufourmantel, N. (2005). Breakthrough in

chloroplas t genetic engineering of agronomically important

crops. Trends in Biotechnology, 23(5).

https://doi.org /10.1016/j.tibtech.2005.03.008

Friess, D. A., Yando, E . S., Alemu I, J. B., Wong, L. W              ., Soto, S. D., &               

Bhatia, N. (2020). Ecosystem services and disservices of

mangrove forests and salt marshes. Oc eanography and

Marine Biology, 58.

https://doi.org /10.1201/9780429351495- 3

Getzner, M., & Islam,  M. S. (2020). Ecosystem services of mangrove

forests: Results of a meta-analysis of economic values.

International Journal of Environmental Research and Public

Health, 17(16). https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph17165830

Greer, A. J., Jacquemin, J., & Hardacre, C. (2020). Industrial

Applications of Ionic Liquids. In Molecules (Vol. 25, Issue 21).

https://doi.org /10.3390/molecules25215207

Hadi, S., Purnomo, Im ron, A., P ristian, R., Ranu, M. E., & Jamil, A. S.

(2024). Adapted Integrated Transformational-Instructional

Leadership Behaviors: Construct Validity and Perceptions

among Teachers and Principals in Indonesian Vocational

Schools. Eurasian Journal of Ed ucational Research,

109(2024), 214–235.

Heimhuber, V., Raoult, V., Glamore, W. C., Taylor, M. D., & Gaston,

T. F. (2024). Restoring blue carbon ecosystems unlocks

fisheries’ potential. Restoration Ecology, 32(1).

https://doi.org /10.1111/rec.14052

Hendarto, T. (2023). Mangroves on Two Islands: Ecological Study in

Java and South Tapanuli. Assyfa Journal of Farming and

Agriculture, 1, 22–32.

Hernández-Blanco, M., Costanza, R., & Cifuentes-Jara, M. (2021).

Economic valuation of the e cosystem services provided by

the mangroves of the Gulf of Nicoya using a hybrid

methodology. Ecosystem Services, 49.

https://doi.org /10.1016/j.ecoser.2021.101258

Himes-Cornell, A., Grose, S. O., & Pendleton, L. (2018). Mangrove

ecosystem service values and methodological approaches to

valuation: Where do we stand? Frontiers in Marine Science,

5(OCT). https://doi.org/10.3389/fmars.2018.00376

Liu, J., Failler, P., & Ramrattan, D. (2024). Blue carbon accounting to

monitor coastal blue carbon ecosystems. Journal of

Environmental Management, 352.

https://doi.org /10.1016/j.jenvman.2023.120008

Lu, Z., Qin, G., Gan, S ., Liu, H., Macreadie, P. I., Cheah, W.,               & Wang,

F. (2024). Blue carbon sink capacity of mangroves

determined by leaves and their associated microbiome.

Global Change Biology, 30(1).

https://doi.org /10.1111/gcb.17007

Lukmandono, E. I., Purba, A. P. P., Ndari, P. W.,               Haslindah, A.,               

Yuniawati, R. D., Ilmi, N., Lestari, R. A., & Putera, D. A. (n.d.).

PENGANTAR TEKNIK  DAN MANAJEMEN INDUSTRI.

Machava-António, V., Fernando, A., Cravo, M., Massingue, M., Lima, H.,